Page Info

Pine Island Shores Real Estate Sold

Mid-Tier
Ultra LuxuryAbove $1,000 per SqFt
High-End$650 - $1,000 per SqFt
Mid-Tier$400 - $650 per SqFt
Premium$300 - $400 per SqFt
Entry-LevelBelow $300 per SqFt
Rank (0)
Reviews (
)
Market Action
Loading
Shows who has more leverage in the market
0–30 favors buyers
30–100 favors sellers
Selling Speed
4
Slow
Shows how quickly homes are being absorbed by buyers
20%+ Fast
8–19.9% Steady
Below 8% Slow
Inventory Supply
25
High
Shows how many months it would take to sell current inventory
0–3 Low
3–6 Balanced
6+ High
Sales Activity
Updating
Awaiting sufficient data
Shows how often homes are selling in this community
2+/mo Active
0.75–1.99/mo Steady
Below 0.75/mo Quiet
Results 13 of 13
Sold - Jan 19, 2026
Pine Island Shores, 2499 Sapodilla Ln, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Shores, 2499 Sapodilla Ln, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$695,000 $55K
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,386 SqFt
  • $501/SqFt
Mid-Tier
House sold in Pine Island Shores
2499 Sapodilla Ln, Other, FL 33956
Just the perfect latitude for your new island attitude. This stunning gulf access home was completely remodeled in 2023. As you head in, the custom tile wall with inlay shelves and built-in electric fireplace sets the tone of style and island luxury. It doesn’t stop there…the custom kitchen with stainless appliances and oversized island provides plenty of space for cooking and entertaining. The split floor plan gives the primary bedroom space and privacy, while the two guest bedrooms sit on the other side of the home. Both the primary and second bathroom have been stylishly tiled and decorated, with even the little touches attended to. The luxury doesn’t end inside. Just steps away from the kitchen is the custom spa and pool with a swim-up bar and gorgeous waterfall feature. This home offers an incredible outdoor space. The captain's walk dock has a 10000# lift and you can be in open waters in just a matter of minutes. This home has all new upgrades, all new wiring, all new plumbing, and all it needs is new owners!
Pine Island Shores, 2347 Sycamore St, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Shores, 2347 Sycamore St, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$910,000 $50K
  • 3 Beds
  • 21/2 Baths
  • 2,350 SqFt
  • $387/SqFt
Mid-Tier
House for sale in Pine Island Shores
2347 Sycamore St, Other, FL 33956
Elegantly renovated waterfront stilt home boasts incredible views of the gulf! This property has 3 bedrooms 2 1/2 bath and an office/ den. Plus home has private elevator! Home offers 2 newly screened in balconies and a screened in porch. Private covered boat dock with water and electricity available. Yard has room for a pool! House sits just 5 doors down from open water offering easy access by boat to sanibel and fort myers beach! Inside the home has been beauifully updated with new lvp flooring throughout, new granite counter kitchen tops, new backsplash, new cabinets and all new appliances! Bathrooms have new vanity, sinks, faucets, tub and shower. Home has been newly painted inside. This waterfront paradise is turnkey and ready to move in!
Pine Island Shores, 2420 Sapodilla Ln, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Shores, 2420 Sapodilla Ln, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$525,000 $50K
  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,173 SqFt
  • $448/SqFt
Mid-Tier
House for sale in Pine Island Shores
2420 Sapodilla Ln, Other, FL 33956
Live the island life you’ve always dreamed of in this cozy, coastal retreat, just minutes from deep, direct gulf access. Whether you’re looking for a full-time residence, a vacation rental, or a smart investment, this home offers it all. With a thoughtful open-concept layout, the home feels spacious yet inviting, while the split floor plan provides privacy between the two master suites. Pocket sliders off the great room open directly to the under-truss lanai, offering seamless indoor-outdoor living .The kitchen is a chef’s dream, with crisp white shaker-style cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, and a chic glass tile backsplash. The island, with its granite countertops, is ideal for meal prep, casual dining, or simply sipping your morning coffee. Step outside to a sparkling heated pool, and relax in your own private oasis. The newer marine wood deck with a boat lift and canopy adds a special touch for those who love to spend time on the water. Whether you're kayaking, fishing, or boating to local restaurants, everything you need to enjoy island life is just minutes away. New roof (2023), outdoor storage shed and new ac give peace of mind, while the serene surroundings offer the perfect backdrop for making lasting memories. Come see for yourself why this cottage is the perfect place to live the ultimate island life. Schedule your showing today! 2010 seahunt boat is also for sale.
Seller Advisory

Start with the right price

Complimentary market intelligence and agent-verified comps for Pine Island Shores homeowners
Market Review
Verified Comps
Pricing Guidance
Pine Island Shores, 3420 1st Ave, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Shores, 3420 1st Ave, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$1,525,000 $25K
  • 3 Beds
  • 21/2 Baths
  • 1,709 SqFt
  • $892/SqFt
Mid-Tier
House for sale in Pine Island Shores
3420 1st Ave, Other, FL 33956
Just reduced! Turnkey home with spectacular breathtaking views with a great location! This remarkable waterfront gulf access pool home is tastefully decorated with a beachy & nautical decor throughout the home and is furnished! This stunning home features cambria quartz countertops, ge high-profile stainless-steel appliances & a kitchen that any gourmet chef would love. New ac ! Relax on your screened in balcony with a cocktail in hand as you watch dolphins & manatees swim by. This open floor plan has some amazing views of pine island south and sanibel island and is a great spot to relax and watch the boats go by. Peace of mind with metal roof, impact windows and doors with plank tile flooring and plantation shutters throughout. Lounge in the heated saltwater pool with your favorite tropical drink and enjoy swfl best sunsets! Enjoy island life with amenities nearby in your own golf cart included in sale ! (golf cart loaded with extras valued around $20k} quick boat ride to local islands & beaches with great fishing in the area! There are 2 covered boat lifts (14k & 7k lbs.) and composite docks with fish cleaning station. Fall in love & make this house your home! Make the move to paradise! *veteran friendly*
Pine Island Shores, 2417 Macadamia Ln, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Shores, 2417 Macadamia Ln, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$475,000
  • 0.25 Acres
  • $1,900,000/Acre
Mid-Tier
Land for sale in Pine Island Shores
2417 Macadamia Ln, Other, FL 33956
Build your tropical island dream home on this cleared gulf access canal. This property is located in a gated community. Home site is located at the southern tip of st. James city, on pine island. Minutes to sanibel, captiva, cabbage key, ft. Myers beach and more . You will be boating to some of the best fishing spots and beautiful beaches.
Pine Island Shores, 2499 Sapodilla Ln, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Shores, 2499 Sapodilla Ln, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$829,000 $30K
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,386 SqFt
  • $598/SqFt
Mid-Tier
House for sale in Pine Island Shores
2499 Sapodilla Ln, Other, FL 33956
Fantastic price adjustment on this gorgeous home! Indulge in the epitome of waterfront luxury. This meticulously renovated canal-front oasis boasts a gourmet kitchen that's a chef's dream, complete with a grand, 10' long quartz island with usb ports. A suite of top of the line appliances include an ice maker that creates bourbon ball-shaped ice, a state-of-the-art convection oven that effortlessly transitions from culinary masterpieces to crispy air-fried delights, beverage fridge, and a cup rinser at the sink. Unwind in spa-inspired bathrooms with bluetooth speakers or immerse yourself in the resort-style ambiance of the custom pool and spa with waterfall feature. Boasting a 10, 000 lb boat lift with remote and canopy. There's even a spot for your friends to dock!!! With immediate access to open waters, this property is a boater's sanctuary. Inside, discover modern comforts including a cozy fireplace, ample storage, and the convenience of a tankless water heater. The exterior showcases a new metal roof, hurricane-rated protection. This fabulous, waterfront home is situated on a lush, corner lot.
Pine Island Shores, 2357 Sapodilla Ln, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Shores, 2357 Sapodilla Ln, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$1,375,000
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,877 SqFt
  • $733/SqFt
Mid-Tier
House for sale in Pine Island Shores
2357 Sapodilla Ln, Other, FL 33956
Sailors and power boaters wanted!!! This stunning and completely remodeled waterfront three-story pool home is a water enthusiast’s paradise! Be on the icw or the gulf of mexico within minutes, with no bridges or locks to navigate. The extensive waterfront is comprised of a large 14’ x 40’ slip, and an 8k lb. Covered boat lift. There is a large custom designed small craft floating dock with a hinged kayak launch and a safety assist bar for easy access. You will enjoy serving cocktails and watching the sunsets from the custom tiki bar with sink, bar refrigerator, and light filtering / privacy screens. The driveway has a large concrete rv pad with twin 50 amp service, and water & sewer connections. The professionally landscaped grounds are designed to be low maintenance. The home has all new exterior hardie plank & shingle siding, a 1.5” snap-lock standing seam system aluminum roof (no exposed screws), with a 25 year warranty, new facia, soffits, & gutters, new impact rated vinyl insulated low-e, argon windows, doors, and a custom made front entry door & sidelights with an ocean dune sea grass design. There is a new hvac system (2024) with a variable speed high efficiency air handler, with both a reme halo & fresh air uv air purifying units, an exterior cargo lift, and a resurfaced pool, with a new 2 story panoramic lanai enclosure. The ground floor includes approx. 912 sqft of two air conditioned shop spaces with impact rated insulated french doors & windows. One is used as a wood shop with sound proofed 8” interior walls and a sound proof closet for the compressor. The flooring has comfortable rubber tiles, and there is a storm rated electric roll up garage door & an electric roll up insect screen. There are (4) dedicated 20 amp circuits for power equipment. The 2nd shop/craft area is being used as an artist/quilt studio and includes a ½ bath and lvp flooring. The handicap accessible interior boasts new lvp flooring throughout, large profile base & door moldings, plantation shutters and custom shades, plus a complete alarm system including sheds, which also monitors for fire, smoke, and motion in the house & shops. The chef’s kitchen is custom designed with all new custom cabinets, new appliances, double wall oven, induction cook top, outside vented exhaust fan, center island, and a butler’s pantry, all with stunning solid surface stone countertops. The laundry room includes a full-size freezer & utility sink. The spacious & private master suite is upstairs with a large west facing balcony overlooking the canal where you can watch the evening sunsets with views of san carlos bay and sanibel island. The 4th story cupola has unobstructed breath-taking distant views of sanibel. This exquisite pine island home is on the southern tip of the island, and must be viewed to truly appreciate every finely executed detail. Please view the video to see how easy it is to launch your kayak and not get wet!
Pine Island Shores, 2292 Sapodilla Ln, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Shores, 2292 Sapodilla Ln, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$659,900 $25K
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 2,005 SqFt
  • $329/SqFt
Mid-Tier
House for sale in Pine Island Shores
2292 Sapodilla Ln, Other, FL 33956
Welcome to this charming waterfront oasis. A beautifully renovated island retreat nestled in the heart of st. James city on pine island, florida. This stunning home is perfectly situated on a deep water canal, offering direct access to some of the best fishing spots in the world and just a short 10-minute boat ride to the pristine, pearl sand beaches of sanibel island. Whether you’re an avid fisherman, a nature lover, or simply seeking a peaceful waterfront lifestyle, this home has it all. Location, location, location.......Enjoy unparalleled access to deep water canals, perfect for boating enthusiasts. Watch dolphins, manatees, and a variety of fish right off your sea walled property. This home boasts an oversized florida floor plan, offering ample space for relaxation and entertainment. The heart of the home features a stunning kitchen with stainless steel appliances, brand-new cabinets, granite countertops, and a convenient pantry closet. It’s the perfect space for preparing meals and entertaining guests. Adjacent to the kitchen, the sunroom provides a serene space to unwind while overlooking the tranquil waterway. The split floor plan ensures privacy, with the main bedroom featuring a stylish barn door, walk-in closet, and a beautifully tiled en-suite bathroom. The two additional bedrooms share a well-appointed bathroom with a tub. The quaint outdoor area is perfect for relaxing in your private spa, surrounded by breathtaking canal views. This is island living at its best. The two-car garage comes equipped with a workbench and shelving, providing plenty of space to keep your belongings organized. Enjoy the laid-back, stress-free lifestyle of pine island, with nearby restaurants and attractions easily accessible by boat or car. 2292 sapodilla lane offers the perfect blend of luxury, comfort, and convenience in a serene, natural setting. Whether you're looking to enjoy the rich wildlife, keep your boat on the newly installed lift and explore the nearby islands, or simply soak up the sun from your own backyard, this home is a true slice of paradise. Don't miss out on the opportunity to make this stunning island home yours. Schedule a showing today and start living the island dream!
Pine Island Shores, 3420 First Ave, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Shores, 3420 First Ave, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$1,550,000 $29K
  • 3 Beds
  • 21/2 Baths
  • 1,709 SqFt
  • $907/SqFt
Mid-Tier
House for sale in Pine Island Shores
3420 First Ave, Other, FL 33956
Just reduced! Turnkey home with spectacular breathtaking views with a great location! This remarkable waterfront gulf access pool home is tastefully decorated with a beachy & nautical decor throughout the home and is furnished! This stunning home features cambria quartz countertops, ge high-profile stainless-steel appliances & a kitchen that any gourmet chef would love. Relax on your screened in balcony with a cocktail in hand as you watch dolphins & manatees swim by. This open floor plan has some amazing views of pine island south and sanibel island and is a great spot to relax and watch the boats go by. Peace of mind with metal roof, impact windows and doors with plank tile flooring and plantation shutters throughout. Lounge in the heated saltwater pool with your favorite tropical drink and enjoy swfl best sunsets! Enjoy island life with amenities nearby in your own golf cart included in sale ! (golf cart loaded with extras valued around $20k} quick boat ride to local islands & beaches with great fishing in the area! There are 2 covered boat lifts (14k & 7k lbs.) and composite docks with fish cleaning station. Fall in love & make this house your home! Make the move to paradise!
Pine Island Shores, 2499 Sapodilla Ln, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Shores, 2499 Sapodilla Ln, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$750,000 $40K
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,386 SqFt
  • $541/SqFt
Mid-Tier
House for sale in Pine Island Shores
2499 Sapodilla Ln, Other, FL 33956
Just the perfect latitude for your island attitude. This stunning gulf access home was completely remodeled in 2023. As you walk in, the custom tile wall with inlay shelves and built in electric fireplace sets the tone of style and island luxury. It doesn’t stop there…the custom kitchen with stainless appliances, and oversized island provide plenty of space for cooking and entertaining. The split floor plan gives the primary bedroom space and privacy while the two guest bedrooms sit on the other side of the home. Both the primary and second bathroom have been stylishly tiled and decorated with even the little touches attended to. The luxury doesn’t end inside. Just steps away from the kitchen is the custom spa and pool with a swim up bar and gorgeous waterfall feature. The captians walk dock has a 10000# lift and you can be in open waters in just a matter of minutes. This home has all new upgrades, all new wiring, all new plumbing, all it needs is new owners!
Pine Island Shores, 2372 Sycamore St, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Shores, 2372 Sycamore St, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$1,120,000 $50K
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,908 SqFt
  • $587/SqFt
Mid-Tier
House for sale in Pine Island Shores
2372 Sycamore St, Other, FL 33956
Location! Location! This property is currently on airbnb making high income. Welcome to your personal oasis, where everyday life feels like a vacation! Experience the ultimate in luxurious living with this stunning waterfront property. Picture yourself enjoying serene mornings with a cup of coffee as you watch boats glide by, or winding down in the evenings surrounded by breathtaking sunsets. This is more than just a home; it’s a lifestyle defined by leisure, adventure, and relaxation. This beautiful home features an open and airy floor plan with abundant natural light, creating an inviting atmosphere throughout. The well-appointed kitchen boasts modern appliances, ample cabinetry, and stunning views, making cooking and entertaining a delight. Enjoy cozy family gatherings in the expansive living room, seamlessly connecting to outdoor spaces through sliding glass doors. Step outside to your private poolside retreat, complete with a screened-in lanai, perfect for al fresco dining or lounging in the sun. The pool offers a picturesque view of the water, enhancing relaxation and entertaining. With a private dock and a boat lift, you have the convenience of direct access to explore the serene waterways or embark on exciting fishing trips at a moment’s notice. The spacious driveway and garage offer plenty of parking space for you and your guests. Located in a vibrant community with nearby shopping, dining, and recreational options, this property is not just a home—it's your gateway to a fulfilling lifestyle. Don't miss your chance to make this dream a reality! Schedule your private showing today.
Pine Island Shores, 3420 1st Ave, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Shores, 3420 1st Ave, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$1,499,000
  • 3 Beds
  • 21/2 Baths
  • 1,709 SqFt
  • $877/SqFt
Mid-Tier
House for sale in Pine Island Shores
3420 1st Ave, Other, FL 33956
Your slice of paradise awaits! Step into this fully furnished, turnkey waterfront masterpiece and prepare to be swept away by breathtaking panoramic views of pine island sound and sanibel island. Nestled in one of southwest florida’s most coveted locations, this gulf-access pool home is a rare gem that blends luxury, comfort, and island charm. Interior elegance meets coastal chic every inch of this home is thoughtfully designed with beachy, nautical décor that instantly transports you to vacation mode. The gourmet kitchen is a chef’s dream, featuring cambria quartz countertops, ge high-profile stainless steel appliances, and a layout perfect for entertaining. Peace of mind & premium upgrades enjoy the security and style of a metal roof, impact-resistant windows and doors, plank tile flooring, and plantation shutters throughout. A new ac keeps things cool, while the shiplap lanai ceiling adds a touch of coastal sophistication. Outdoor living at its finest sip cocktails from your screened balcony as dolphins and manatees glide by. Take a dip in the heated saltwater pool, then unwind with the best sunsets in swfl. With two covered boat lifts (14k & 7k lbs.), composite docks, and a fish cleaning station, your waterfront lifestyle is ready to launch. Island adventures & ultimate convenience hop in your included golf cart (valued at $20k and loaded with extras) and explore nearby amenities, or cruise to local islands and beaches for world-class fishing and relaxation. This is more than a home—it’s a gateway to the island life you’ve always dreamed of. Fall in love. Move to paradise. Whether you're seeking a serene retreat or a vibrant coastal lifestyle, this home delivers it all. Don’t just buy a house—claim your piece of paradise.
Pine Island Shores, 2321 Macadamia Ln, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Shores, 2321 Macadamia Ln, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$998,000 $97K
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,977 SqFt
  • $505/SqFt
Mid-Tier
House for sale in Pine Island Shores
2321 Macadamia Ln, Other, FL 33956
New photos! New wood flooring in all bedrooms, including primary hall and walk-in closets!!! New ceiling fans throughout home (installed 4/29), new path to dock, new decking at dock (to be installed). Newly painted balcony furniture with new cushions. Refreshed primary bedroom with new bedding, desk area, and freshly painted en-suite bath. Both secondary bedrooms and bath redone as well. Private gated community of pine island shores. New roof 2023, new boatlift 2022 (new motors 2023), new water heater 2022, new pool heater 2020, new a/c 2019. Property has 88' concrete seawall, and 10, 000 lb. Boatlift just off the pool deck. Hurricane shutters cover front door, all windows, and upper level balcony/lanai. Whole home protection. Extensive covered patio area under the balcony for more entertaining. The deep water canal provides direct access to the gulf of mexico! Short ride to icw, sanibel, captiva, pine island sound, and cabbage key! The other side of the community is flanked with a wildlife conservation area , providing beautiful views and protection from storms. Enjoy family time in this beautiful home, poolside, or out on the water.

Subdivision Amenities

Bike Storage
Fish Cleaning Station
Internet Access
Park
Storage
Streetlight
Bike And Jog Path
Bike Storage
Boat Storage
None
See Remarks
Underground Utility

Market Peers

Matched by price tier, HOA, and lifestyle
Results 0 of 0
No listings found
Try adjusting your filters or changing your location to see available listings
Turn on listing alerts and we'll notify you
when matching listings appear

Scores

Walk Score®
Car-Dependent. Almost all errands require a car
2

100
Bike Score®
Somewhat Bikeable. Minimal bike infrastructure
25

100
Sound Score®
Bearable noise
83

100
Airport Score
Close to airports. Noticeable airport activity
0

100
Traffic Score
Congested area. Frequent traffic delays
24

100
Local Score
Limited local amenities nearby
0

100

Other
Mid-Tier
Mid-Tier Homes & Condos

Related Searches in Other, FL

Map
Filters
HomeSearchHome ValueProfile