Page Info

Pine Island Tropical Homesites Houses SoldNo HOA

Entry-Level
Ultra LuxuryAbove $1,000 per SqFt
High-End$650 - $1,000 per SqFt
Mid-Tier$400 - $650 per SqFt
Premium$300 - $400 per SqFt
Entry-LevelBelow $300 per SqFt
Rank (0)
Reviews (
)
Market Action
Loading
Shows who has more leverage in the market
0–30 favors buyers
30–100 favors sellers
Selling Speed
8
Steady
Shows how quickly homes are being absorbed by buyers
20%+ Fast
8–19.9% Steady
Below 8% Slow
Inventory Supply
12.5
High
Shows how many months it would take to sell current inventory
0–3 Low
3–6 Balanced
6+ High
Sales Activity
Updating
Awaiting sufficient data
Shows how often homes are selling in this community
2+/mo Active
0.75–1.99/mo Steady
Below 0.75/mo Quiet
Results 12 of 12
Sold - Aug 22, 2025
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3468 Citrus St, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3468 Citrus St, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$283,500 $16K
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,032 SqFt
  • $275/SqFt
Entry-Level
House sold in Pine Island Tropical Homesites
3468 Citrus St, Other, FL 33956
Welcome home to island paradise. This 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home is the perfect getaway. Whether this is your full-time residence, vacation getaway, or setting it up as a rental and producing income, this home checks all the boxes! Selling turnkey! Brand new ac, solid wood soft closing cabinets with quartz countertops. Tiled backsplash. Located on a very quiet street, community boat ramp in walking distance! The perfect set up for a boater! Enjoy the outdoor living area with a large covered lanai with an oversized lot.
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3468 Citrus St, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3468 Citrus St, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$265,000 $21K
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,292 SqFt
  • $205/SqFt
Entry-Level
House for sale in Pine Island Tropical Homesites
3468 Citrus St, Other, FL 33956
Gulf access under $300k! Fully remodeled home on pine island! Featuring 3 bedrooms 2 bathrooms this home is a boater's paradise! Community boat ramp located at end of the street - launch your boat and enjoy fishing, boating, and beaches in minutes. Practically brand-new, this home has been remodeled down to the studs. The modern kitchen is a highlight with stainless steel appliances, gorgeous backsplash, a center island, and pass through to the dining. Tile throughout - no carpeting! New paint, lighting, fans, everything!!! Large bedrooms great for your personal island vacation home, visiting company, or year-round living. This private stretch of pine island offers over a quarter acre of trees, privacy, and the open water close by. Close to shopping centers, groceries, restaurants, seafood, and the relaxed island salt life that the florida gulf coast is famous for!
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3455 Papaya St, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3455 Papaya St, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$112,500
  • 2 Beds
  • 1 Baths
  • 1,249 SqFt
  • $90/SqFt
Entry-Level
House for sale in Pine Island Tropical Homesites
3455 Papaya St, Other, FL 33956
This property is a diamond in the rough for the right buyer. Ideal for investors, flippers, or diy enthusiasts looking to capitalize on the well sought after real estate market in st. James city. With a complete renovation, this home has the potential to significantly increase in value and become a stunning showcase property. Seize the opportunity to invest in this property situated in the desirable area, offering ample potential for those with a vision for transformation.
Seller Advisory

Start with the right price

Complimentary market intelligence and agent-verified comps for Pine Island Tropical Homesites homeowners
Market Review
Verified Comps
Pricing Guidance
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3662 Papaya St, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3662 Papaya St, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$530,000
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,683 SqFt
  • $315/SqFt
Entry-Level
House for sale in Pine Island Tropical Homesites
3662 Papaya St, Other, FL 33956
This beautiful 3-bed 2 bath 1680 sq. Ft. Home with pool and outdoor living space area is located in the tropical homesites subdivision. This well-maintained home has a repainted exterior in 2021 and the interior was repainted in 2022. The property also has newly installed landscaping and a well-groomed lawn. The metal roof was installed in the spring of 2022. Also new shaker style kitchen cabinets with dolomite stone counter tops, induction stove and new microwave. As you walk into this open concept plan home you will be immersed in natural light amplified by the 11-foot vaulted ceilings. The open living area gives direct access through sliding doors to the saltwater pool within the screen enclosure. The screen enclosure has been repainted, rescreened and new fasteners installed in 2023. The outside pool deck includes a large, covered living space area to enjoy the view of nature surrounding much of this property. The master bedroom also has a vaulted ceiling and sliding door access directly to the pool deck area. You’ll love the natural light flowing into the large master bath that has a european design influence and new 36” high shaker style cabinets with quartz countertop.
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3633 Mango St, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3633 Mango St, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$412,000
  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,325 SqFt
  • $311/SqFt
Entry-Level
House for sale in Pine Island Tropical Homesites
3633 Mango St, Other, FL 33956
New listing! Charming newer built (2019) island home in saint james city on historic pine island! No damage/no flooding from ian! Higher elevation than most! Tropical homesites has extra long lots and kayak/small boat launch and only beach on island at tropical point park. Community allows golf carts on main roads w/easy access to shopping, restaurants, entertainment, boating, fishing & more. This beautiful home is concrete block w/desirable hardie board exterior. Home has spray foam insulation (not blown in) which saves on electric bills plus close fire hydrant for savings on insurance. Home has beautiful kitchen w/stainless appliances, granite counters, tiled backsplash & island w/butcher block top. Bathrooms updated w/gorgeous tiled shower & granite. Other great features include: metal roof, city water, sprinkler system, walk in closets, vaulted ceilings & shelves, oversized indoor laundry room w/wash tub, x-long driveway, huge deck off back of home and plenty of room for pool in spacious back yard. Willing to sell furnished w/right offer. Home had contract w/sale of another home but buyer was unable to perform/hence days on market. Inspection & appraisal went well. Call today!
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3598 Tangelo Dr, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3598 Tangelo Dr, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$330,000
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,132 SqFt
  • $292/SqFt
Entry-Level
House for sale in Pine Island Tropical Homesites
3598 Tangelo Dr, Other, FL 33956
Newer built "olde florida" designed stilt home! Welcome to st. James city on historic pine island. Tropical home sites offers large lots and a community park with bbq grills, picnic tables and a small beach area where you can enjoy the beautiful views of matlacha pass. This three bedroom two bathroom home was not damaged by hurricane ian. This 3 bedroom, 2 bath "furnished" home is perfect for island living and that florida keys "lifestyle pine island is known for. High 14' volume ceiling, all impact windows and doors, large lot with plenty of room for a future pool. Lots of room on first level for garages and building out a work shop, man cave or additional recreation area. Walk or ride your golf cart to all the best in st. James city for boating, fishing, resturnats and island entertainment. This home offers great vacation rental income possibilities. Hvac system was completely replaced 3 years ago and has a 10 year warranty. Home comes with one year complete home warranty for total buyer comfort. Won't last long, hurry and buy!
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3775 Papaya St, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3775 Papaya St, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$276,500 $17K
  • 2 Beds
  • 11/2 Baths
  • 1,010 SqFt
  • $274/SqFt
Entry-Level
House for sale in Pine Island Tropical Homesites
3775 Papaya St, Other, FL 33956
Floor elevation 9'8"above sea level never had floodwaters inside house adorable tropical cottage featuring open plan concept with exposed beam cathedral ceiling. 2 bedroom, 1 1/3 bath. Screened lanai under truss + patio. Turn key- all furnishings included as shown. Brass queen bed in master br, desk in br #2 with double bed. Available now! Imm occupancy or rent out. Hide-a-bed in living room - house sleeps 6 total. Overbuilt by architect himself. Metal hip roof- storm panels. Walk to tropical point beach park, kayak launch ramp+ small boat ramp. Quiet rural island area. Very unique house. Must see. Additional sink in master br. No rules here: park boat or campers on lot. Stained concrete floor throughout.
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3756 Tropical Point Dr, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3756 Tropical Point Dr, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$295,000
  • 2 Beds
  • 1 Baths
  • 888 SqFt
  • $332/SqFt
Entry-Level
House for sale in Pine Island Tropical Homesites
3756 Tropical Point Dr, Other, FL 33956
Huge price reduction!!!!!Awesome home 2/1 on pine island. Move in ready. Large back yard, new roof in 2018, appliances, water heater, plumbing and cabinets. Totally updated and furnished!!!! It is located in tropical point that has a park, ramp for small boat or kayak and great fishing. Great community in good location for peace and quiet. Close to restaurants and shops. The owner will contribute up to $10, 000 toward closing costs.
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3471 Papaya St, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3471 Papaya St, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$180,000 $95K
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,444 SqFt
  • $125/SqFt
Entry-Level
House for sale in Pine Island Tropical Homesites
3471 Papaya St, Other, FL 33956
Hurricane ian damaged home ready for a dream make over! Located mid-way st. James city at tropical point right around the corner from a community park and small beach area to enjoy. Public boat ramp. Oversized lot.
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3582 Papaya St, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3582 Papaya St, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$469,000 $6K
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,207 SqFt
  • $389/SqFt
Entry-Level
House for sale in Pine Island Tropical Homesites
3582 Papaya St, Other, FL 33956
Enjoy the peace and tranquility of island living in this super clean cozy cottage that sits on a 2/3-acre lot in a quiet neighborhood on pine island southwest of florida. It is within a few minutes walking distance to tropical point park with available water access point for kayaks and small boats, 4 miles to local shops, restaurants, supermarkets, and under 5 miles to matlacha - a small island known for colorful arts and fishing community. In late september of 2022, hurricane ian hit hard on sanibel and pine island and created significant damages to the entire area of southwest florida. Our property was in 4 feet of sea water, it was devastated. But we were determined to rebuild it and we did it in a record time. We proudly announce this property of ours was completely repaired and renovated by the first week of march 2023.Roof 2021 today this property is more beautiful than before; its interior has been redesigned with a modern looking and with an open floor concept. It has new drywalls, new paint of course, all new doors, new floors, new kitchen cabinets as well as many new appliances. Most furniture is relatively new too. The master bedroom has a queen size bed and a full private bathroom, the second bedroom has a full-size bed, and the third bedroom has two twin size beds. There is a shared full bathroom at the hallway. The kitchen is fully equipped with cookware, dinnerware, drinkware, etc. Just grab some groceries at the market and cook a meal or visit the wonderful moms and pops restaurants nearby. There're 2 smart tvs, 2 bikes available in the premises and a beautifully heated swimming pool for your enjoyment; and full washer and dryer for your convenience. The property is ideal for those who prefer quieter neighborhood and for those who love water activities, fishing, walking, biking, visiting fruit farms, or remote-working or even doing nothing. It is also a great getaway for couples or families to vacation together. You will have full access to the cottage, tucked away from the hustle and bustle of the noisy city, where you can enjoy the peace and tranquility of island living that pine island has to offer. This home is on an extra large lot perfect for anyone who enjoys gardening , fruits and more. This home is currently a successful vacation rental home and is perfect for someone looking to get in that business !!
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3519 Papaya St, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3519 Papaya St, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$459,000 $20K
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,469 SqFt
  • $312/SqFt
Entry-Level
House for sale in Pine Island Tropical Homesites
3519 Papaya St, Other, FL 33956
Get ready to enjoy island living in this recently renovated 3 bed + den, 2 bath home built in 2020 located in st. James city. The home sits on almost 1/3 acre lot in pine island tropical homesites. The community has a county park with beach area and a boat launch just minutes from your front door. The boat launch connects with the great calusa blueway paddling trail. The community has paved roads, city water and no hoa fees. Upon arriving at the home you will notice the new 2023 metal roof, paver driveway and screened front porch. Upon entering the home into the great room you will see the beautiful kitchen featuring new cabinets and appliances, granite countertops with a large island with a vaulted ceiling making this great room grand. There is a bright and roomy den off the great room perfect for a home office. The large master bedroom suite features dual walk-in closets, brand new carpet and a generous master bath with a walk in shower and new vanity. Both guest rooms have new carpet, double door closets and share a beautifully updated guest bathroom. All new stylish light fixtures & ceiling fans have been installed throughout. The laundry room has a new washer and dryer. The 2 car garage has epoxy floors. You'll love sitting on the back patio enjoying the peace & tranquility while overlooking your huge backyard.
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3756 Tropical Point Dr, Other, Florida 33956, image 1
Pine Island Tropical Homesites, 3756 Tropical Point Dr, Other, Florida 33956, image 2
$245,000 $10K
  • 2 Beds
  • 1 Baths
  • 600 SqFt
  • $408/SqFt
Entry-Level
House for sale in Pine Island Tropical Homesites
3756 Tropical Point Dr, Other, FL 33956
Awesome home 2/1 on pine island. Move in ready. Large back yard, new roof in 2018, appliances, water heater, plumbing and cabinets. Totally updated and furnished!!!! It is located in tropical point that has a park, ramp for small boat or kayak and great fishing. Great community in good location for peace and quiet. Close to restaurants and shops.

Subdivision Amenities

Beach Access
Internet Access
Park
See Remarks
Barbecue
Community Boat Ramp
Community Gulf Boat Access
Internet Access
None
Park

Frequently Asked Questions

Market Peers

Matched by price tier, HOA, and lifestyle
Results 0 of 0
No listings found
Try adjusting your filters or changing your location to see available listings
Turn on listing alerts and we'll notify you
when matching listings appear

Nearby Subdivisions

Entry-Level
2.58 miles
For Sale (1)
$345K - $345K
Entry-Level
2.66 miles
Entry-Level
3.37 miles
Entry-Level
3.54 miles
For Sale (2170)
$105K - $7M
For Rent (294)
$2K - $21K

Schools

Scores

Walk Score®
Car-Dependent. Almost all errands require a car
0

100
Bike Score®
Somewhat Bikeable. Minimal bike infrastructure
32

100
Sound Score®
Very quiet
86

100
Airport Score
Close to airports. Noticeable airport activity
0

100
Traffic Score
Congested area. Frequent traffic delays
16

100
Local Score
Limited local amenities nearby
0

100

Other
Entry-Level
Entry-Level Homes & Condos

Related Searches in Other, FL

Map
Filters
HomeSearchHome ValueProfile