Valuation
Who We Are
Blog
Light Theme

Castaway Key Real Estate For Sale

Loading...

Loading...

Loading...

High-End
Ratings
Reviews (
)
AI Filter
Results 5 of 5
Castaway Key, 4511 Schooner Dr, Upper Captiva, Florida 33924, image 1
$929,000
  • 3 Beds
  • 31/2 Baths
  • 1,608 SqFt
  • $578/SqFt
House for sale in Castaway Key
4511 Schooner Dr, Upper Captiva, FL 33924
Charming north captiva island getaway with a fully upgraded exterior! Thoughtfully crafted with a reverse floorplan that maximizes light, space, and beautiful tropical surroundings. The open-concept living area seamlessly extends to a spacious screened lanai, perfect for indoor-outdoor living. The galley-style kitchen features a large dining bar & walk-in pantry. Two primary suites with en suite baths offer private walk-in showers. A versatile den serves as the bunk room, providing a fourth sleeping area for guests. The fully upgraded exterior combines convenience with peace of mind. This home boasts impact-resistant doors & sliding glass doors, new pgt energy-efficient, argon-filled, low e glass impact-resistant windows, maintenance-free composite decking, aluminum railings, a new composite vinyl siding rated for 150-mph winds with a lifetime color warranty, and a top-of-the-line highly durable fiberglass/epoxy lanai deck. Other recent upgrades include a new roof with a transferable premium warranty, new energy-efficient hvac units with wi-fi programable thermostats, and new kitchen appliances. The adjacent vacant lot is also available for purchase - offering an opportunity for added privacy, expanded outdoor space, or even a future guest house. Plus, a share in a private beach lot is available for exclusive beach access. Convenient home location, just a short walk to the beach, ferry, and resort amenities. There is plenty of room to add a pool. Excellent rental potential. Priced well below reconstruction cost, this is an exceptional value for island living! Don't miss this chance to own an affordable island retreat - schedule your showing today!
Castaway Key, 621 Rum Rd, Upper Captiva, Florida 33924, image 1
$1,700,000 $145K
  • 3 Beds
  • 31/2 Baths
  • 2,481 SqFt
  • $685/SqFt
House for sale in Castaway Key
621 Rum Rd, Upper Captiva, FL 33924
Major price reduction. This gorgeous home, 3 bedroom + den & 4 baths, has everything you would llove to have on upper captiva island. Gulf access canal home with a large dock. Room for 2 boats & located on a navigable canal. Come see the wonderful views overlooking the wildlife preserve. The living area is on the upper floor to more enjoy the views of the state wildlife preserve. All hurricane impact glass windows. Cedar shiplap exterior siding. Wood burning fireplace. And the views are even better from the upper mezzanine area above the living room which could be another sleeping area. Plenty of room for guests with 3 bedrooms, a den and 3.5 bathrooms. Huge beautiful kitchen. Enjoy a large pool completely screened in. The beach is just down the road to a parking area with access to the widest beach on the island. New roof. Elevator! What more do you need! Make an appointment to see this wonderful home.
Castaway Key, 631 Rum Rd, Upper Captiva, Florida 33924, image 1
$1,595,000
  • 4 Beds
  • 4 Baths
  • 1,920 SqFt
  • $831/SqFt
House for sale in Castaway Key
631 Rum Rd, Upper Captiva, FL 33924
Your private island waterfront escape — where every sunrise feels like it’s just for you! Imagine waking up to the first blush of sunrise spilling over pine island sound, the sky glowing pink and gold, while you sip coffee on your upper deck with panoramic views over a protected nature preserve. Just the soft rustle of palm fronds, the call of shorebirds, and the quiet lapping of water against your private dock. This isn’t just a house — it’s a 4-bedroom, 4-bath sanctuary built in 2020 to the highest storm and structural codes, so you can relax knowing your island retreat is as strong as it is beautiful. Inside, light pours in through vaulted ceilings onto airy, coastal-inspired living spaces. The designer kitchen — quartz countertops, stainless appliances, and custom cabinetry — was made for both sunset dinner parties and barefoot brunches after a morning swim. Built with impact windows, hardie board siding, and a metal roof, this home is built to withstand the elements. Step outside, and your world opens to a screened, heated pool surrounded by lush native landscaping that melts into the untouched preserve. When the day calls for adventure, your dock on a peaceful canal is ready for your boat, with quick access to some of the best fishing waters in florida. Whether you’re searching for a top-performing vacation rental or a personal hideaway that earns its keep when you’re away, this home is already a proven income generator — and it comes turnkey, so you can start living (or renting) the dream on day one. Opportunities for move-in waterfront properties don’t pop up on north captiva island very often — especially ones that offer this level of privacy, views, and modern construction. The only question is: will you let someone else watch your sunrise? Call today before this one disappears over the horizon.
THINKING OF SELLING YOURPROPERTY IN Castaway Key?
We can help

Sell Faster

For Top Dollar

With The Best Terms

Castaway Key, 560 Gulf Ln, Upper Captiva, Florida 33924, image 1
$1,899,000 $301K
  • 2 Beds
  • 21/2 Baths
  • 1,650 SqFt
  • $1,151/SqFt
House for sale in Castaway Key
560 Gulf Ln, Upper Captiva, FL 33924
One of the most private and charming beach front homes ever for sale on north captiva island! This exquisite old florida cottage-style home offers true character and a a unique living experience with its one of a kind beachfront location. This rare lot is generously oversized, owning all the way to the mean high tide line... Surrounded on both sides by multiple non-buildable lots for unmatched privacy on the beach. The captivating charm of the cottage architecture & decor sets this home apart in a league all of its own. Every moment at this beach house is an all-encompassing retreat to nature and island life. The cottage interior features shiplap walls, tongue & groove ceilings, and meticulously painted woodwork with modern comforts like sleek kitchen countertops w/ stainless steel appliances. The eclectic style showcases handcrafted details, cozy nooks, and a warm ambiance that welcomes you at every turn. Ownership of this beachfront cottage is not just a home, but a serene sanctuary where timeless memories will be etched into the very fabric of your life. Don't miss your one and only chance to own this very special and unique property!
Castaway Key, 4430 Smugglers Dr, Upper Captiva, Florida 33924, image 1
$165,000
  • 0.33 Acres
  • $500,000/Acre
Land for sale in Castaway Key
4430 Smugglers Dr, Upper Captiva, FL 33924
Oversized corner lot bordering rum rd.  Just steps from club amenities, shopping, dining, and the ferry landing. Bay and harbor views from the highest levels!    2 adjacent lots on schooner dr. Also available. Make an offer today!
Similar Communities & Listings
Results 0 of 0
No Listings Found

We couldn't find any listings in your search area. Try changing your location

Subdivision Amenities

Underground Utility
Beach - Private
Beach Access
None

Scores

Walk Score®

Car-Dependent. Almost all errands require a car.

13

100

Transit Score®

No data.

N/A

Bike Score®

Bikeable. Some bike infrastructure.

52

100

Sound Score®

No data.

N/A

Upper Captiva
High-End Homes & Condos

Logo

Broker reciprocity logoLocal Realty Service Provided By: Hyperlocal Advisor. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Information is provided, in part, by Greater Miami MLS & Beaches MLS. This information being provided is for consumer's personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any other purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.

Copyright © 2025 Subdivisions.com • All Rights Reserved • Made with ❤ in Miami, Florida.
Map
Filters
HomeSearchValuationProfile