Natoma Park Single Family Homes For Sale

Fort Myers, FL 33919

LISTINGS MARKET TRENDS DEMOGRAPHICS

Results 14 of 14

$799,000

$749,000

Natoma Park

5621 Natoma Dr, Fort Myers, FL 33919

MLS# 224091197

Beds

Baths

3,551

SqFt

6.3% Decrease (-$50,000)

Garage

$211

$/SqFt

A fisherman's paradise awaits you!...this expansive, oversized lot with 184 feet of prime water frontage offers a rare opportunity to own a slice of waterfront heaven. With both waterfront and preserve views, this property is truly one-of-a-kind. Properties in this location are rarely available, making this an exceptional find. Enjoy your own composite wood captain’s walk, private boat ramp, boat lift, and covered boat house—everything you need for the ultimate waterfront lifestyle. This .54-acre lot provides a remarkable opportunity to either customize the existing 4,000 sq. Ft. Home to suit your tastes or build a brand-new dream home with endless possibilities. Whiskey creek has been a well-kept local secret for years, offering unparalleled fishing and boating access right in your own backyard. Quick access out to the intercostal, gulf & bay waters, you’ll have great access to some of florida’s best boating, fishing, beaches, shelling, waterfront dining, and more. The home itself features an updated kitchen and bathrooms, newer appliances, an expansive laundry room, and a large florida great room. Whether you choose to renovate the interior, build new, or raise the existing structure, the potential is limitless. The choice is yours—this is your chance to experience florida living on the waterfront for a great value and investment.

Royal Shell Real Estate, Inc.

$525,000

Natoma Park

5541 Winkler Rd, Fort Myers, FL 33919

MLS# 224078559

Beds

Baths

2,222

SqFt

0.0%

Garage

$236

$/SqFt

Florida retro 1970 designed ruttenberg home! Remodeled, renovated & upgraded $150,000+/- this 2,222 a/c sf, 3 bedroom, den, 3 full baths, 2 car garage home has it all and ready for a new owner and comes with a complete one year "home warranty" for total buyer comfort. Some of the unique features of the home are brand new roof, retro terrazzo floors in main living area with tile in the other areas of the home. Home has 12' cathedral ceiling and a split floor plan for guest and family privacy. Master bedroom has volume ceilings, 2 full bathrooms (could be converted into amazing walk-in closet. Master has a "stacking" triple slider onto a very spacious lanai. Home sits on oversized lot with mature plantings in highly sought after and desirable neighborhood, close proximity to downtown. The living area is expansive with an opportunity to enlarge the kitchen and/or create a home office space or even 4th bedroom. Back yard is large and has plenty of room for a pool, in the future. The side yard is wide enough and large enough for rv or your boat storage. New ac in 2020, hot water heater replaced in 2019. Home is close to downtown ft. Myers, rsw int'l airport, schools, churches, hospitals, restaurants and the best of ft. Myers entertainment. Make this retro home a "must see"!

Coldwell Banker Realty

$334,900

$324,900

Natoma Park

1020 El Mar Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33919

MLS# 224069944

Beds

Baths

1,364

SqFt

2.6% Decrease (-$10,000)

Garage

$238

$/SqFt

Fha, va, conventional financing or cash! Great opportunity for a first time home buyer or investor! Beautiful property. Great home for the price, 3/2/2, fully renovated, brand new roof, new kitchen and bathroom cabinets with granite countertops, fresh paint inside and out, tile throughout the house, huge back yard. Great location, bring your buyers!!! Send offer with pre-approval letter or proof of funds.

Best Florida Homes LLC

Service by Hyperlocal Advisor

THINKING OF SELLING YOURSingle Family Home IN Natoma Park?

3D Virtual Tour

Professional Photos

Syndicated Exposure

$419,900

$399,900

Natoma Park

1024 El Mar Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33919

MLS# 224072940

Beds

Baths

1,606

SqFt

4.8% Decrease (-$20,000)

Garage

$249

$/SqFt

Welcome home to this gorgeously renovated single family estate located in natoma park, which is a mature community in the highly sought after area of whiskey creek and mcgregor! This home offers 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, tile throughout, tons of natural light and a resort style pool complete with a waterfall! The kitchen boasts custom two tone soft close cabinetry, quartz countertops and ss appliances. New air conditioner in 2021, full house replumb in 2019, new pool pump in 2023. Enjoy outdoor living in your fully fenced and private backyard, full of gorgeous native plants, bushes and trees. The location is perfect for walking the mcgregor and whiskey creek neighborhoods. With close proximity to the beaches, shopping, dining, health park, rsw intl airport, spring training, downtown cape coral, downtown fort myers and much more!

Royal Shell Real Estate, Inc.

$259,000

Natoma Park

1020 El Mar Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33919

MLS# 224036562

Beds

Baths

1,017

SqFt

0.0%

Garage

$255

$/SqFt

Seller is taking offers until may 9,2024, and a decision on the offers will be decided by the seller on may 10 2024. This presents a wonderful opportunity to renovate a home in a highly desirable location. The property features two bedrooms, two full baths, and a two-car garage, as well as a spacious, attractive fenced-in yard. Additionally, the central location is in close proximity to a variety of amenities, including stores, medical facilities, and restaurants.

John R. Wood Properties

$399,900

Natoma Park

1008 El Rio Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33919

MLS# 224025467

Beds

Baths

1,524

SqFt

0.0%

Garage

$262

$/SqFt

Step into timeless charm with this captivating 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home nestled in the highly sought-after area between mcgregor and college pkwy, just off winkler. This residence offers a unique blend of modern updates and classic elegance, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. The recently updated (2022) kitchen is a standout feature, boasting stylish cabinets, quartz countertops, and stainless steel appliances that create a modern and functional space. Whether you're preparing a meal for your family or entertaining guests, this kitchen is sure to impress. With both a living room and a family room, as well as a spacious formal dining area, there's plenty of room for relaxation and socializing. The master bedroom serves as a peaceful retreat, complete with a walk-in closet and an updated vanity in the master bathroom. The guest bedrooms are generously sized and share a well-appointed guest bathroom. Throughout the home, brand new luxury plank flooring adds a touch of elegance and modern appeal. Step outside onto the screened lanai, perfect for enjoying the florida weather and al fresco dining. The backyard offers ample space for play and relaxation, making it ideal for families and outdoor enthusiasts alike. Additional features include a durable metal roof, an ac unit installed in 2018, and a hot water heater installed in 2022, ensuring your comfort and peace of mind. Welcome to your new home, where classic charm meets modern convenience, creating a space you'll love coming back to day after day.

RE/MAX Realty Team

$573,000

$568,000

Natoma Park

1040 E Shaddelee Ln, Fort Myers, FL 33919

MLS# 224080297

Beds

Baths

1,926

SqFt

0.9% Decrease (-$5,000)

Garage

$295

$/SqFt

* seller offering $5,000 towards buyer's closing costs or to buy down the interest rate. * tropical oasis in your own backyard! 4 bedrooms | 2 bathrooms | heated pool with no hoa! The true wow factor! Modern kitchen and bathroom remodel (2023). Huge kitchen island for cooking and entertaining. Farmhouse copper sink. Split floor plan, ample storage throughout, crown molding, and new interior doors. Plantation shutters for additional elegance. Beautiful pool with new pool pump and heater (2024). Experience the convenience of the true pool bath. Retractable awning extends to edge of the pool, added in 2023. Newer roof (2021) third nail system and double wrap straps (huge insurance reduction). Trane ac with extra split primary bedroom ac with separate control (2023). New tankless water heater and appliances (2023). New lg washer and dryer (2024). Fully fenced with storage shed and outdoor shower. Extra attic insulation installed which keeps electric bills low. New electrical upgrade with grounding and surge protection (2024). Craftsman t-100 36" riding mower (new in sept 2024) included with the home purchase. Only city taxes. Make this beauty home! Flood insurance can be transferred ($2,400). Homeowner insurance ($1,980). Close to restaurants and shopping. No flooding or damage from helene or milton!

Weichert Realtors Agency ONE

$450,000

Natoma Park

1056 Bayshore Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33919

MLS# 223060612

Beds

Baths

1,520

SqFt

0.0%

Garage

$296

$/SqFt

Natoma park is an established neighborhood of single family homes located in south fort myers, along whiskey creek. This home is on a preferred corner lot with a circular drive way to a side entry garage. Enjoy your morning coffee or entertaining friends on the large oversized screened lanai with a tranquil view of lush trees and native plants. This home has a new kitchen remodel with new appliances. Aluminum impact resistant hurricane windows with additional energy savings. New air conditioning system with whole house filter and uv light. All electrical wiring up to date with new weather head. Entire house surge protector. 220' irrigation well with distribution lines (no staining iron in water). Abs plastic drain plumbing. Tankless water heater. Standing seam metal roof (kynar). Bright white finish providing significant summer energy savings (reflective roof). The home is located in a preferred location by mcgregor blvd.

Genesis Realty Team

$600,000

Natoma Park

5554 Natoma Dr, Fort Myers, FL 33919

MLS# 225004347

Beds

2¹/₂

Baths

1,997

SqFt

0.0%

Garage

$300

$/SqFt

Super location, beauty, and comfort! Pool & spa home! This newly remodeled home combines modern design with thoughtful details, offering 1,911 square feet of air-conditioned living space. Featuring 4 bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms, it provides the perfect blend of style, comfort, and functionality. The centerpiece of the home is the stunning kitchen, equipped with top-of-the-line appliances, sleek cabinetry, and ample counter space—a dream for cooking and entertaining. The open floor plan seamlessly connects the kitchen to the spacious living area, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. The primary suite offers a peaceful retreat with plenty of natural light and well-appointed finishes, while the additional bedrooms provide flexibility for guests, a home office, or a hobby room. A dedicated indoor laundry room enhances everyday convenience. Step outside to your private backyard oasis, featuring a pool and spa with a waterfall set in a beautifully landscaped yard. It’s the perfect spot to relax or host gatherings. Additional highlights include a newer roof (2021), ensuring peace of mind, and an immaculate 2-car garage that provides both functionality and pristine organization. Located in a well-established neighborhood, this home sits just across from a wide gulf-access canal, surrounded by stunning waterfront properties. Its prime location offers easy access to local amenities, shopping, dining, and outdoor activities, making it an exceptional place to call home. Experience the perfect combination of modern living, quality upgrades, and serene surroundings. Schedule your private showing today!

Cozza Realty Group Inc

$374,900

Natoma Park

1034 El Rio Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33919

MLS# 225000481

Beds

Baths

1,221

SqFt

0.0%

Garage

$307

$/SqFt

This stunning 2 bedroom + den, 2 bathroom home in fort myers has been fully remodeled with over $150,000 in upgrades, making it completely move-in ready. The property also includes architectural drawings for a planned addition of a primary bedroom, bathroom, and office, offering an additional 700 square feet of space. Every detail of this home has been thoughtfully updated, starting with a complete plumbing re-pipe, including the removal and replacement of all cast iron drains and lines to the street. Major updates include a new roof, new air conditioning system with updated ductwork, new hot water heater, and exterior paint. Inside, you’ll find new ceramic tile flooring throughout, freshly painted walls and trim, new attic insulation, and stylish crown molding. The kitchen and bathrooms have been fully remodeled with modern finishes, new appliances, while all new windows, sliders, and a hurricane-impact front door provide peace of mind. The home features a panoramic screen porch, perfect for enjoying the outdoors, and a large fully fenced backyard with a new fence and lush professional landscaping by exclusive r.s. Walsh, including the design, and a calusia hedge for privacy ($20k update). Additional features include a new impact-rated garage door (up to 185 mph), custom closet systems, new interior doors, baseboards, and trim. A negative mold test was completed in november 2024 (report is available). Located off the iconic mcgregor boulevard, this home is just minutes from restaurants, shopping, entertainment, and all the best that fort myers and cape coral have to offer including a+ rated schools, all without hoa fees. This is an exceptional opportunity to own a beautifully updated home in a prime location! Some photos include reality renovation/staging. *this property includes design services, making updates, as shown, easy for your buyer*

Cornerstone Coastal Properties

$600,000

Natoma Park

1016 E Shaddelee Ln, Fort Myers, FL 33919

MLS# 224092093

Beds

Baths

1,740

SqFt

0.0%

Garage

$345

$/SqFt

Bring the outdoors in with this beautifuly sun shiny home! From the moment you walk in you will fall in love with all the light shining in through the "wall of windows" on the rear of the home. With three sets of triple sliders, one set of double sliders and windows galore you will feel the warm welcoming this home has to offer. This open floor plan rutenberg pool home has been lovingly updated and upgraded. The kitchen has beautiful new cabinetry, granite countertops, stainless appliances, new oversized deep sink and a large breakfast bar. The kitchen opens up into the dining area and the living area which allows all the light to shine through. The laundry room is set off to the side of the kitchen and has plenty of cabinets for extra storage. The master bedroom has an en-suite and walk-in closet. This home features a split bedroom floor plan with the two extra bedrooms separated from the master bedroom. Both bathrooms have been completely updated including glass shower enclosures, new shower tile, new vanities and new tile floors. The main living area opens up to the backyard which features a large covered lanai area and beautiful in ground pool. The privacy fence around the backyard allows you to enjoy your pool to the fullest. The pool has plenty of pavers surrounding it, allowing you to use your imagination for all the extra space. Put a fire pit out there and enjoy the outdoors year round. Sit at the pit or relax on the lanai with your favorite beverage and enjoy the ambiance of your pool with the night time lighting features. This home is located off the majestic and sought after mcgregor corridor. The location is ideal for trips to the beaches, downtown fort myers, shopping and restaurants. This lovely home and perfect location will allow you to enjoy all that sunny southwest florida has to offer. You will want to put this on your must see list - it will not disappoint.

Jones & Co Realty

$549,000

Natoma Park

1020 El Rio Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33919

MLS# 224096526

Beds

Baths

1,587

SqFt

0.0%

Garage

$346

$/SqFt

Experience paradise living at its best in this totally remodeled charmer! 3 bedroom/2 bath pool home in a super convenient location near everything. When you enter this property, you feel right at home. New metal roof (2023), gorgeous new kitchen with shaker cabinets, quartz counter tops, backsplash, ss apps. And custom island (2023). Both bathrooms have all new fixtures, quartz countertops and a new shower in the guest bath (2023), plus an outdoor shower! (the whole house was re-plumbed). There is a whole house culligan water system! The a/c & hot water heater were replaced (2023) plus an added a/c split in the 2 car garage with new hurricane rated auto garage door. New fans, lighting and ltv flooring throughout the entire home. The outdoor area is awesome...lots of room to entertain and relax by the heated pool (new pump) with brick paver deck. There's a 6' vinyl fenced-in back yard with raised garden beds, 3 fruit trees (mango, avocado & lemon) and a fire pit area. All new impact glass windows, hurricane shutters on lanai and front door. The curb appeal has been recently enhanced with all new professional landscaping (november 2024). No hoa! Come see…you will not be disappointed!

Berkshire Hathaway Homeservice

$425,000

Natoma Park

1039 El Mar Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33919

MLS# 224020644

Beds

Baths

1,145

SqFt

0.0%

Garage

$371

$/SqFt

This completely renovated, mid century modern home in the highly sought after area of whiskey creek and mcgregor is a must see! This home offers 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, tons of natural light and a contemporary open living concept. The kitchen boasts custom soft close cabinetry, quartz countertops and ss appliances. Bathrooms have custom soft close cabinetry, tile showers and lighted mirrors. Light oak tile plank flooring throughout - no carpet. Bedroom closets offer plenty custom shelving. Sliders in the owner's suite opens up to private sitting area within the lanai that is separate from the outdoor living space. The lanai overlooks the spacious and well maintained backyard with room for a pool. Rv plumbing hookup is capped. Location is phenomenal for walking the mcgregor and whiskey creek neighborhoods. Close proximity to the beaches, shopping, dining, health park, rsw intl airport, spring training, downtown cape coral, downtown fort myers and much more!

RE/MAX Realty Group

$1,479,900

Natoma Park

5539 Natoma Dr, Fort Myers, FL 33919

MLS# 224103742

Beds

3¹/₂

Baths

3,481

SqFt

0.0%

Garage

$425

$/SqFt

Spectacular, waterfront home, with access to the gulf just mile away. This home has tons of upgrades. 28x18 spectacular master bedroom, with a massive 14x13 walk-in closet. Luxury tub, walk-in tile shower with duel sinks. Utility room in master, with additional utility room on the other side of the home. Additional master suite, with full bath and walk-in closet. New flooring and custom tile floors. Spacious kitchen, with tons of cabinets, island, solid granite counter tops, walk-in pantry and upgraded appliances. Crown molding, with 5" baseboards. Recessed lighting, lots of windows for natural light. 25x12 covered lanai looking at pool, spa, canal & boat lift. 30x12 covered front porch. Lots storage and so much more. Come see for yourself!

Royal Shell Real Estate, Inc.

Community Snapshot

N/ABedrooms

$259K to $1.5MPrice Range

1,017 - 3,551SqFt Range

1970Year Build

1Total Floors

N/ATotal Units

Subdivision Amenities

Guest Room

Streetlight

Fish Cleaning Station

None

See Remarks

Sidewalk

Storage

Frequently Asked Questions

What is included in the Natoma Park monthly association dues?

The single_family_home dues at Natoma Park cover: None, Cable, Trash Removal, Water, Other.

What are Natoma Park Pet Policies & Restrictions?

Natoma Park Natoma Park is a pet-friendly “Dogs and Cats OK” subdivision for both owners and tenants. Please note that pet policies may change at the discretion of management and/or the Homeowners' Association (HOA) and may not apply to renters. Restrictions may apply to certain breeds, and size and weight limits may be in place.

What are the interior features of the residences?

Natoma Park Interior features include: Bar, Built-In Cabinets, Pantry, Smoke Detectors, Window Coverings, Built-In Cabinets, French Doors, Laundry Tub, Pull Down Stairs, Tray Ceiling(s), Walk-In Closet(s), Laundry Tub, , Window Coverings, Cathedral Ceiling(s), Custom Mirrors, Foyer, Multi Phone Lines, Foyer, Smoke Detectors, Walk-In Closet(s), Closet Cabinets

What are the available unit views from Natoma Park?

Natoma Park unit views: Landscaped Area, Pool/Club, Canal, Preserve, , Partial Buildings, Water

Schools

Scores

Walk Score^®

Car-Dependent. Almost all errands require a car.

100

Transit Score^®

No data.

N/A

Bike Score^®

Somewhat Bikeable. Minimal bike infrastructure.

100

Sound Score^®

Bearable noise.

100

Fort Myers Economic Homes & Condos