Butterknife Real Estate

Sanibel, FL 33957

LISTINGS MARKET TRENDS DEMOGRAPHICS

Results 3 of 3

$1,750,000

Butterknife

2239 Starfish Ln, Sanibel, FL 33957

MLS# 224002626

Beds

Baths

2,572

SqFt

0.0%

Garage

$680

$/SqFt

Welcome to paradise! This stunning and elegant 3 br/3 ba elevated home in butterknife, one of sanibel's finest neighborhoods, is so close to the beach you can almost feel the sand between your toes. Step into the inviting foyer and your eyes will instantly be drawn to the soaring cathedral ceilings and cupola that bathes the great room in sunlight. Travertine floors grace the main living areas and a large chef's kitchen boasts bar seating and a separate dining area, offering ample space for entertaining family and friends. Open the pocket sliders in the great room to enjoy gulf breezes on the expansive 65-foot lanai, creating the island lifestyle we all dream of. Relax poolside or in the spa sipping tropical beverages and enjoy all day sun with this home's perfect southern exposure. The primary suite features a large walk-in closet and bath with soaking tub and oversized walk-in shower. The slider from the suite to the lanai is perfect for listening to the sounds of the gulf while enjoying your morning coffee. Guest bedrooms and den all offer access to outdoor space, including two private balconies. This coastal oasis truly offers the best of island living!

McCallion and McCallion

$1,995,000

Butterknife

2312 Starfish Ln, Sanibel, FL 33957

MLS# 225017046

Beds

3¹/₂

Baths

2,833

SqFt

0.0%

Garage

$704

$/SqFt

Welcome to 2312 starfish lane, an exceptional residence in the only gated community on prestigious west gulf drive. Just across the street from the beach, this 1.1-acre residence offers deeded beach access and an unparalleled sense of privacy, overlooking miles of protected land in frannie’s preserve, where tropical vegetation and island wildlife create a serene backdrop. Designed for luxury and resilience, this elevated home is built on oversized pilings and features hurricane-resistant upgrades, including impact-rated doors and windows, a new 2023 miami-dade-rated standing seam metal roof, and an engineered pool enclosure secured with concrete footers and stainless-steel anchors. Outdoor living is effortless with a spacious brick paver pool deck, offering covered and uncovered areas for year-round enjoyment. The private pool and spa provide a tranquil retreat, surrounded by lush natural landscaping. Inside, custom brazilian lyptus wood cabinetry enhances beauty and sustainability, while over 2,000 square feet of garage and storage space accommodate hobbies, sports equipment and multiple vehicles. The original building plans included accommodations for the hassle-free addition of a private elevator in the future if desired. Elevator shaft and pit are in place for easy build-out. In recreational and biking distance to island restaurants and attractions, this home is close to everything while offering a peaceful escape. The community also features pickleball and tennis courts, a pool with a pool house, and a private security gate. A rare opportunity to own a newer-built, worry-free residence in an exclusive enclave, offering affordability and peace of mind.

Premier Sotheby's Int'l Realty

$949,000

Butterknife

2133 W Starfish Ln, Sanibel, FL 33957

MLS# 222063965

Land

0.0%

N/A

Lot

Rare opportunity to own one of the last lots left in butterknife! This private gated community is steps to deeded beach access and offers community pool and tennis. Located at the end of a quiet cul-de-sac this parcel is over 25,000 square feet and has plenty of room to build your dream house and still enjoy your privacy. Lot can have a home with 5,848 sf of living space and 3,283 sf of non a/c space - total sf - 9,132. Upscale neighborhood with estate sized homes, casa ybel resort and one of sanibel's finest beach front dining spots are just a stroll away from this unique offering. Plans available. Site plan, environmental assessment, and soil bore available.

Flat Fee MLS Realty

Service by Hyperlocal Advisor

THINKING OF SELLING IN Butterknife, FL?

3D Virtual Tour

Professional Photos

Syndicated Exposure

Community Snapshot

N/ABedrooms

$949K to $1.8MPrice Range

2,572 - 4,146SqFt Range

2003Year Build

2Total Floors

N/ATotal Units

Subdivision Amenities

Community Room

Pickleball

Pool

See Remarks

Storage

Tennis Court(s)

Beach - Private

Beach Access

Schools

Scores

Walk Score^®

Car-Dependent. Almost all errands require a car.

100

Transit Score^®

No data.

N/A

Bike Score^®

Very Bikeable. Biking is convenient for most trips.

100

Sound Score^®

Bearable noise.

100

Sanibel Mid-Range Homes & Condos