Old Cutler Common Houses Sold

Q: How much are the maintenance fees (HOA) in Old Cutler Common?

The current monthly maintenance fee at Old Cutler Common is ~0.05 per unit SqFt.

Q: What is included in the Old Cutler Common monthly association dues?

The single_family_home dues at Old Cutler Common cover: Common Areas, Maintenance Structure, Recreation Facilities, Common Area Maintenance.

Q: What are Old Cutler Common Pet Policies & Restrictions?

Old Cutler Common Old Cutler Common is a pet-friendly “Dogs and Cats OK” subdivision for both owners and tenants. Please note that pet policies may change at the discretion of management and/or the Homeowners' Association (HOA) and may not apply to renters. Restrictions may apply to certain breeds, and size and weight limits may be in place.

Q: What are the interior features of the residences?

Old Cutler Common Interior features include: Built In Features, Closet Cabinetry, Dining Area, Separate Formal Dining Room, Eat In Kitchen, Custom Mirrors, Main Level Primary, Attic, Entrance Foyer, First Floor Entry, Pantry, Bedroom On Main Level, Vaulted Ceilings, Walk In Closets, Breakfast Bar, Dual Sinks, Living Dining Room, Shower Only, Stacked Bedrooms, Kitchen Island, Breakfast Area, Eatin Kitchen, French Doors Atrium Doors, Main Level Master, Sitting Areain Master, Atrium, Tub Shower

Q: What are the available unit views from Old Cutler Common?

Old Cutler Common unit views: Garden, Lake, Pool, None

Rank (0)

Reviews (

)

Own a unit here?

No units match this filter

Real Estate Owner & Seller Storage & Parking Market Insights Demographics

Results 23 of 23

Sold - Apr 14, 2026

Old Cutler Common, 21405 SW 97th Pl, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 1

Old Cutler Common, 21405 SW 97th Pl, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 2

Old Cutler Common, 21405 SW 97th Pl, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 3

$850,000

5 Beds
3 Baths
2,609 SqFt
$326/SqFt

House sold in Old Cutler Common21405 SW 97th Pl, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

Welcome to the largest home in the subdivision, featuring a brand-new tile roof, fully remodeled pool and jacuzzi (2025), and shutters throughout, all set on an oversized 14, 392 sqf lot. The 5/3 expansive house was completely remodeled in 2025, offering a modern, open layout with custom cabinetry, quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, and updated bathrooms, including a convenient cabana bath. Step outside to a private backyard retreat where the resort-style pool and jacuzzi, enhanced by dramatic evening lighting, create the perfect space for entertaining or relaxing. The oversized lot provides rare privacy and flexibility within the community. Ideally located just 2 minutes from the florida turnpike and within walking distance of the upcoming cutler bay government center, featuring a community center, outdoor fitness circuit, splash pad, scenic canal overlook, community garden, and expansive green space—adding long-term lifestyle and value. This property stands out as a truly rare opportunity in cutler bay.

Old Cutler Common, 21420 SW 97th Pl, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 1

Old Cutler Common, 21420 SW 97th Pl, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 2

Old Cutler Common, 21420 SW 97th Pl, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 3

$715,00060K

4 Beds
2 Baths
1,924 SqFt
$372/SqFt

House for sale in Old Cutler Common21420 SW 97th Pl, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

Enjoy spectacular lakefront living in this spacious, re-built 2012 cutler bay home on an oversized lot with breathtaking sunset views. This 4-bed, 2-bath home is filled with tons of natural light, featuring vaulted ceilings, crown molding, and impact windows/doors. Step into a backyard oasis: 750 sq ft covered patio with electric screens, fire pit, hammock, and oversized yard — perfect for a pool, playground, or more. On a recreational spring-fed lake, enjoy swimming, kayaking, and fishing year-round. Includes an enclosed area for your motorboat or rv. Just 2 minutes from the florida turnpike and 5 minutes from black point marina. Surrounded by nature, this rare lakefront gem won’t last long.

Old Cutler Common, 9755 SW 215th Ln, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 1

Old Cutler Common, 9755 SW 215th Ln, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 2

Old Cutler Common, 9755 SW 215th Ln, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 3

$595,000130K

4 Beds
2 Baths
2,056 SqFt
$289/SqFt

House for sale in Old Cutler Common9755 SW 215th Ln, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

Depending on offer, seller will consider assistance with closing costs. Bring everything! This move in ready 4/2, home features tiled throughout, 1 car garage, recessed lighting, crown moldings, freshly painted. High ceilings, new kitchen with wood cabinetry, granite countertops and new appliances. Remodeled bathrooms. Formal dining room, living room and family room. Step outside to the spacious screened patio ideal for gatherings. Hurricane shutters, newer roof and newer a/c unit. Closets galore. Enjoy the variety of fruit trees, coconut, banana, pomegranate and much more. Room for a pool.

Old Cutler Common, 9750 SW 214th Ter, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 1

Old Cutler Common, 9750 SW 214th Ter, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 2

Old Cutler Common, 9750 SW 214th Ter, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 3

$695,00024K

4 Beds
3 Baths
1,924 SqFt
$361/SqFt

House for sale in Old Cutler Common9750 SW 214th Ter, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

Welcome to this beautifully designed 4/3 home, featuring a sparkling screened pool and covered patio. Step inside to a spacious floor plan, lots of light throughout, washer/dryer, hurricane shutters. The master suite is a true retreat boasting walk in closet, spa like bath and french doors leading to the pool. Tiled throughout and laminate wood flooring in bedrooms. Newer a/c, roof, and new pool pump. Custom made kitchen with walnut cabinetry, new appliances, granite countertop, butcher block. Converted garage can be used as an in-law quarters or office. **dining room lamp is excluded from the sale**

Old Cutler Common, 21545 SW 97th Pl, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 1

Old Cutler Common, 21545 SW 97th Pl, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 2

Old Cutler Common, 21545 SW 97th Pl, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 3

$545,000

3 Beds
2 Baths
1,543 SqFt
$353/SqFt

House for sale in Old Cutler Common21545 SW 97th Pl, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

Come visit this one story three-bedroom, two-bathroom plus garage family home which sits high above the road on a 12, 0000 sf corner lot. One of the largest lots in the area. This home is ready for your personal touches. The living room has high ceilings and a lot of natural light. Master includes an ensuit bathroom and ample closet space. A screen enclosed patio with view to a lush garden is perfect for evening gatherings and relaxing. Lakes by the bay is a quite family community located minutes from black point park and marina, and the turnpike.

Old Cutler Common, 9755 SW 214th Ter, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 1

Old Cutler Common, 9755 SW 214th Ter, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 2

Old Cutler Common, 9755 SW 214th Ter, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 3

$680,000

4 Beds
2 Baths
1,924 SqFt
$353/SqFt

House for sale in Old Cutler Common9755 SW 214th Ter, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

Immaculate family home located minutes from black point park and marina, and less than 1 mile of turnpike. Come visit this one story, four-bedroom, two-bathroom home with enchanted zen gardens. Spacious design with high ceilings, both formal and informal gathering areas. An open den and kitchen combination is perfect for family time. The kitchen is complete with an eat-in island. With a brand-new roof and air condition unit, as well as impact-resistant windows and doors, this house provide peace of mind. The expansive backyard boats lush fruit trees and space for a pool.

Old Cutler Common, 21425 SW 98th Ct, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 1

Old Cutler Common, 21425 SW 98th Ct, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 2

Old Cutler Common, 21425 SW 98th Ct, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 3

$725,00025K

4 Beds
2 Baths
1,924 SqFt
$377/SqFt

House for sale in Old Cutler Common21425 SW 98th Ct, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

The best of indoor & outdoor lakefront living * located on quiet cul-de-sac * elevated & beautifully landscaped oversized lot * charming front patio entrance leading to double front doors * foyer entry with direct views to the captivating lake * vaulted ceilings in formal living & dining rooms offer a spacious feel * light & bright kitchen with center island & breakfast area * plenty of natural lighting throughout * tranquil lake views from the entire back of the home * 18.2' x 54.7' screened in & covered backyard patio with captivating lake views * 2 private docks (a fixed & a floating dock) * wooden stairs leading down to the lakefront with approximately 107 feet of waterfront * 2015 tiled roof * newer appliances & much more * move right in to this delightful home * see broker remarks *

$525,000125K

5 Beds
3 Baths
2,609 SqFt
$201/SqFt

House for sale in Old Cutler Common21405 SW 97th Pl, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

A big house 5/3 with pool agents please note the following important information! This property is currently in some distress. Seller (personal representative) has never resided in property and has no guarantee of property condition. This was a probate which is now finalized. However, there are liens and title defects which are being cured but might take some additional time to cure before closing. Seller selects title company, this is not negotiable. Please submit any offers with seller selected. Seller will not work with another title company since part of title work has already been completed and title defects are being worked on.

Old Cutler Common, 21414 SW 98th Ct, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 1

Old Cutler Common, 21414 SW 98th Ct, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 2

$589,00016K

4 Beds
2 Baths
1,924 SqFt
$306/SqFt

House for sale in Old Cutler Common21414 SW 98th Ct, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

Look no further, this house was made to enchant. Fantastic lake view steps from old cutler road. Beautiful subdivision of old cutler common in the desirable city of cutler bay, very pedestrian community with a lovely scenery full of mature tress in a great school district. This house has the chalet style with an open concept and tons of natural light coming in throw the windows, the wide double door entrence for the majestic feeling and a spacious back yard to entertain friends and families. Lots of space in order to accommodate a large family a one car garage and sufficient parking extra in the driveway and in front of the house. Don't miss the opportunity because this great home could be yours. Call today and schedule an appointment.

Old Cutler Common, 9760 SW 214th Ter, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 1

Old Cutler Common, 9760 SW 214th Ter, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 2

$607,50018K

4 Beds
2 Baths
1,924 SqFt
$316/SqFt

House for sale in Old Cutler Common9760 SW 214th Ter, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

Immaculate family home located minutes from black point park and marina, and the turnpike. Come visit this one story, four-bedroom, two-bathroom home with enchanted zen gardens. Spacious design with high ceilings, both formal and informal gathering areas and a bonus large, covered terrace. An open den and kitchen combination is perfect for family time. The kitchen is complete with an eat-in island, granite counter tops and stainless-steel appliances. Relax in an oversize master bedroom with private en-suit bathroom which includes a vanity make up area. The second bathroom is updated with all the bells and whistles including a back-lite vanity mirror. This corner lot is 10, 491 sf, one of the largest lots in the neighborhood.

Old Cutler Common, 9750 SW 215th Ln, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 1

Old Cutler Common, 9750 SW 215th Ln, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 2

$590,00059K

3 Beds
2 Baths
1,543 SqFt
$382/SqFt

House for sale in Old Cutler Common9750 SW 215th Ln, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

Reduced to sell fast !!!Beautiful pool home in quiet bay estates, lakes by the bay east of old cutler rd. This is 3/2 with large patio, pool and jacuzzi. Lush tropical landscaping, on oversized lot has it all, living room + dining room w/ views of your pool. Extra large master bedroom with abundant closet space. Single car garage. Only blocks from neighborhood parks and playgrounds, top national rated public and charter schools, bike paths throughout quiet canal system. Impact doors and windows and generator ready in case of power shortage. Third room is used as family room but can be easily converted.

Old Cutler Common, 9737 SW 213th Ter, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 1

Old Cutler Common, 9737 SW 213th Ter, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 2

$625,000

4 Beds
2 Baths
1,924 SqFt
$325/SqFt

House for sale in Old Cutler Common9737 SW 213th Ter, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

This beautiful family home greets you with high ceilings as you enter the foyer area. French doors and windows give plenty of natural light and expansive backyard views. This home has 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms and an oversized 2 car garage that sits on an extra-large lot on a cul-de-sac with views of community lake with beach access in cutler bay. Formal living and dining room with extra high ceilings. Kitchen with island and seating. Lovely master suite with french doors that leads to patio. Extra-large backyard terrace for entertaining.

Old Cutler Common, 9800 SW 215th Ter, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 1

Old Cutler Common, 9800 SW 215th Ter, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 2

$521,000

4 Beds
2 Baths
1,924 SqFt
$271/SqFt

House for sale in Old Cutler Common9800 SW 215th Ter, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

Tons of renovation potential for this 4 bedroom, 2 bath home on an oversized lot in lakes by the bay. Great floor plan. Formal living and dining room. Kitchen with garden view and island with seating. Lovely master suite with sliding glass door that leads to the patio. The backyard features a covered patio and screened garden. Oversized 2 car garage plus storage area.

$485,000

4 Beds
2 Baths
1,924 SqFt
$252/SqFt

House for sale in Old Cutler Common21414 SW 98th Ct, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

Rare opportunity to purchase in this quiet neighborhood of bay estates located in lakes by the bay. This home offers 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms and 1 car garage and sits on a quiet cul-de-sac. Open kitchen with granite counters, stainless steel appliances, open living and kitchen, family room with tile throughout. Beautiful outdoor living and great for entertaining your guests with a newly renovated patio-deck with surface boards. Also enjoy a lakefront view and breeze right from your front porch and just a short walk away, bring your beach chair, a cold tropical drink so you can sit down and relax on a sandy lakefront beach. This community is conveniently located close to biscayne national park and black point park and marina, parks, shopping, restaurants, old cutler rd, fl turnpike and us1.

Old Cutler Common, 21227 SW 97th Pl, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 1

Old Cutler Common, 21227 SW 97th Pl, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 2

$375,00010K

3 Beds
2 Baths
1,584 SqFt
$237/SqFt

House for sale in Old Cutler Common21227 SW 97th Pl, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

Mrs. Clean lives here! This cozy home is light and bright and immaculate! Lovely cul-de-sac location in lakes by the bay. Vaulted ceiling, large picture window in the living room, wood floors throughout, family room off the eat-in kitchen, and large screened patio, perfect for your bbq. The master bedroom has sliding doors to the backyard and a large bathroom with double sinks. Accordion hurricane shutters, one-car garage, sprinkler system. This house is pristine and will sell quickly.

Old Cutler Common, 9765 SW 215th Ln, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 1

Old Cutler Common, 9765 SW 215th Ln, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 2

$300,00045K

4 Beds
2 Baths
1,924 SqFt
$156/SqFt

House for sale in Old Cutler Common9765 SW 215th Ln, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

Great location!! This 4 bedroom 2 bath home is located on a large fenced corner lot in the lakes by the bay community. Close to shopping dining and easy access to the fl turnpike. Easy to show

$420,000

4 Beds
2 Baths
1,924 SqFt
$218/SqFt

House for sale in Old Cutler Common21420 SW 97th Pl, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

Amazing west-facing sunset views are just one of the highlights of this custom renovated home. 4 bed/2 bath complete with travertine flooring throughout and a spacious common living area with vaultes ceilings, crown molding, and huge sliding glass doors to frame the stunning lakeview sunsets. Back yard playground, fire pit, & a raised bed organic garden in view of the 800+ sq ft rear covered terrace that boasts a huge sundance hot tub and retractable motorized screens. Renovated kitchen with granite & ss appliances, completely upgraded bathrooms with solid wood cabinetry & granite, travertine showers, dual-flush toilets, & a separate laundry room with extra ac area storage & single garage with built in storage shelving. This is a home renovated with care and attention to detail.

Old Cutler Common, 9760 SW 215th Ln, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 1

Old Cutler Common, 9760 SW 215th Ln, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 2

$365,000

3 Beds
2 Baths
1,584 SqFt
$230/SqFt

House for sale in Old Cutler Common9760 SW 215th Ln, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

Beautiful 1 story cutler bay home with 3 spacious bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms sitting on a 10, 000+ sq ft lot. This home has it all: new roof, impact windows & doors, custom window shades and the perfect back yard for entertaining. Very easy to show.

Old Cutler Common, 21410 SW 98th Ct, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 1

Old Cutler Common, 21410 SW 98th Ct, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 2

$347,000

4 Beds
2 Baths
1,924 SqFt
$180/SqFt

House for sale in Old Cutler Common21410 SW 98th Ct, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

On the lakes by the bay offers multiple jogging paths, lakes, and lots of green areas... Conveniently located close to many shoppings and plenty of dining options.. A must see property!

Old Cutler Common, 21520 SW 97th Pl, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 1

Old Cutler Common, 21520 SW 97th Pl, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 2

$799,000

4 Beds
2 Baths
2,533 SqFt
$315/SqFt

House for sale in Old Cutler Common21520 SW 97th Pl, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

Welcome to your lakefront oasis, with a bonus room that is being utilized as a 4th bedroom. The yard is equipped with a dock, outdoor kitchen, turfed side yard, and expansive deck. It sits on one of the few natural spring-fed lakes in the area, making it swimmable and safe for water sports. The chef's kitchen has plenty of cabinet and countertop space and the dining/family room offers serene lake views. The home boasts a newer roof (2018), 5 ron a/c (2021), water heater (2023), impact windows, electrical panel (2024) and pvc pipes. Furthermore, the house has easy access to the turnpike, black point marina, and great schools. Bring your golf cart and fishing rod to experience the best of cutler bay living! Don't miss out on the tranquil sunsets in this slice of paradise.

$600,000

5 Beds
3 Baths
2,609 SqFt
$230/SqFt

House for sale in Old Cutler Common21405 SW 97th Pl, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

Spacious 5 bedroom 3 full baths. Featuring a spacious floor plan, large kitchen area with formal dining, and huge formal family room. Tiled and carpet floors throughout, 2 a/c units. Barrel tile roof, sits on a 14, 000 sq ft lot, and large backyard with oversized pool. Home needs some tlc, but has great potential. Excellent community in old cutler bay!

Old Cutler Common, 21505 SW 97th Ct, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 1

Old Cutler Common, 21505 SW 97th Ct, Cutler Bay, Florida 33189, image 2

$639,000

5 Beds
3 Baths
2,500 SqFt
$256/SqFt

House for sale in Old Cutler Common21505 SW 97th Ct, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

Charming family home in the highly sought-after community of cutler bay, just minutes from black point park, marina, and convenient access to the turnpike. This spacious one-story residence offers five bedrooms and three bathrooms, including a private in-law suite with its own entrance. The oversized primary bedroom boasts ample space for a home office or cozy sitting area. Designed for both comfort and style, the home features high ceilings, an open layout perfect for gatherings, and a beautifully remodeled kitchen with granite countertops. Enjoy peace of mind with a newer roof and impact-resistant windows and doors. A perfect blend of space, function, and location—this home is a must-see!

$679,000

5 Beds
3 Baths
2,500 SqFt
$272/SqFt

House for sale in Old Cutler Common21505 SW 97th Ct, Cutler Bay, FL 33189

1985

Year Build

Total Units

Subdivision Amenities

Maintenance

HOA Cost Benchmark

This Community

$0.05

Comparable Entry-Level Avg

$0.04

Cutler Bay, FL Avg

$0.13

$0.00

$0.08

$0.15

Higher than peers, lower than the city average

Peer Set · 5 comparable communities

See Cost Context

Frequently Asked Questions

How much are the maintenance fees (HOA) in Old Cutler Common?

What is included in the Old Cutler Common monthly association dues?

What are Old Cutler Common Pet Policies & Restrictions?

What are the interior features of the residences?

What are the available unit views from Old Cutler Common?

Market Peers

Matched by price tier, HOA, and lifestyle

Results 0 of 0

No listings found

Try adjusting your filters or changing your location to see available listings

Turn on listing alerts and we'll notify you
when matching listings appear

Preconstruction in Cutler BayShow All

Caribbean Isles 2

Condos in Cutler Bay, FL 33157

Units
142
Stories
8

Miami-based Caribbean Village LTD., an affiliate of Pinnacle Housing, hopes to get approval for revised plans regarding the second phase of Caribbean Isles.

The first phase, which finished construction in 2019, currently offers 123 units geared toward seniors. The second phase would offer 142 affordable housing units in an eight-story building. This is a 42 percent increase from the initially proposed 100 in 2022.

According to the South Florida Business Journal, plans call for the construction of 90 one-bedroom and 52 two-bedroom units, with communal amenities including a fitness center and club room. There would also be a two-story parking garage featuring 96 parking spots, averaging to less than one per unit. Behar Font & Partners designed the venture.

The second phase would take shape on a 3.23-acre site.

Caribbean Isles’ second phase is slated for 19755 S.W. 110th Court, Miami, FL, 33157, in Miami-Dade County. It’ll be west of the Florida Turnpike in the South Miami Heights neighborhood.

APARTMENT AMENITIES