House in Sanibel, FL 33957Butterknife, 2179 Starfish Ln
Closed






3
Beds31/2
Baths2,730
SqFt$538
$/SqFtMid-Tier HouseProperty Type
2007Year Built
$538/SqFtPrice per sq ft
$2,562/moHOA Fees
4 carsParking Spaces
Landscaped Area, Pool/ClubView
MOTIVATED SELLER. Welcome to Sanibel Island! This home and gated community offer an exceptional blend of natural beauty, lush, tropical grounds, and a community that supports an active lifestyle. Sanibel is renowned for its stunning beaches, rich wildlife, and an array of outdoor activities that cater to all tastes and preferences. Whether it's a peaceful stroll along the shore, visiting the local boutiques or an adventurous day exploring the island’s many trails, Sanibel is a paradise waiting to be discovered. The Butterknife neighborhood is a gated haven, characterized by exclusivity and charm. Only 34 distinguished homes grace this community, fostering a close-knit environment that is both inviting and secure. Here, life unfolds with access to Sanibel's iconic 25-mile shared-use path, making it easy for residents to enjoy cycling, jogging, and embracing the local outdoors. Nearby, an assortment of dining and shopping opportunities enrich everyday living. As for the home itself, prepare to be enamored by its large yet intimate living spaces. Designed for both comfort and elegance, each of the spacious bedrooms includes an ensuite bathroom, offering a personal retreat for everyone. The inviting deck and patio lead to a large pool and together set the stage for both lively gatherings and tranquil afternoons under the sun. Future-friendly features such as tall ceilings and an interior elevator ensure the home is suited for all stages of life, pallowing residents to embrace aging in place with sophistication. Practical elements like a garage large enough for cars and work benches plus hurricane protection add extra layers of convenience to this exceptional residence.
Listing Courtesy Of: McCallion and McCallion
Local Realty Services Provided By: Best of Luxury Realty
Updated: 149 Days agoPage Views: 0
Features
MLS Number: 2025017977
Bedrooms
- Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms
- Bathrooms: 3
- Half Bathrooms: 1
Exterior and Lot Features
- Exterior Features: Balcony, Open Porch/Lanai, Screened Lanai/Porch
- View: Landscaped Area, Pool/Club
Interior, Heating and Cooling
- Interior Features: Disability Equipped, Exclusions, Foyer, French Doors, Laundry Tub
- Equipment / Appliances: Dishwasher, Dryer, Microwave, Range, Refrigerator/Icemaker, Tankless Water Heater, Washer
- Heating Description: Central Electric, Zoned
- Cooling Description: Ceiling Fan(s), Central Electric, Zoned
Building and Construction
- Floor Description: Concrete, Tile, Wood
- Windows/Treatment: No info
- Construction Type: House
- Year Built: 2007
- Style: Two Story, Single Family
Waterfront and Water Access
- Waterfront Frontage: No info
School Information
Other Property Info
- Garage: 4
- Pets Allowed: Yes
Taxes, Fees & More
- Maintenance Includes: Legal/Accounting, Manager, Rec Facilities, Reserve, Security
- Taxes: 12808.43
- Security Information: Gated Community
- Parking Description: Driveway Paved, Under Bldg Closed, Attached
- Total Floors in Building: 2
- Total Units in Building: 1
Apples-to-Apples Comparables
Price History
Current
$1.5M
High
$1.7M
Low
$1.5M
Total Change
-10.9%Date
Event
Price
Change
Price Per
06/25/2026
Sold
$1.5M
0%$538 ft2
$5,796 m2
02/13/2026
Price Reduced
$1.5M
-1.93%$538 ft2
$5,796 m2
02/13/2026
Price Reduced
$1.5M
-6.25%$549 ft2
$5,910 m2
01/26/2026
Price Reduced
$1.6M
-3.09%$586 ft2
$6,305 m2
11/10/2025
Listed
$1.7M
$604 ft2
$6,506 m2
06/25/2026
$1.5M
Event
Sold
Change
0%Price Per
$538 ft2
$5,796 m2
02/13/2026
$1.5M
Event
Price Reduced
Change
-1.93%Price Per
$538 ft2
$5,796 m2
02/13/2026
$1.5M
Event
Price Reduced
Change
-6.25%Price Per
$549 ft2
$5,910 m2
01/26/2026
$1.6M
Event
Price Reduced
Change
-3.09%Price Per
$586 ft2
$6,305 m2
11/10/2025
$1.7M
Event
Listed
Price Per
$604 ft2
$6,506 m2
Price per square foot and days on website are not provided values and are calculated by Subdivisions.
Listed by Susan McCallion • McCallion and McCallion • Buyer Agency Compensation .
Community Snapshot
5 – 5 BR
Bedrooms
$1.7M – $1.7M
Price Tier
2,572 - 4,146
SqFt Range
2003
Year Build
2
Total Floors
Subdivision Amenities
Beach Access
Community Room
Pickleball
Pool
See Remarks
Storage
Tennis Court(s)
Barbecue
Beach - Private
Beach Access
Pool
All Sanibel, FL Mid-Tier Mid-Tier Homes & Condos
- Anchors Aweigh House3
- Bayshore Village House3
- Bayview Village Condo0
- Beach Road Villas Villa2
- Beachview Country Club Estates Mixed10
- Bright Water House3
- Butterknife Mixed1
- Caloosa Shores House0
- Castaway Estates House3
- Chateaux Sur Mer Mixed1
- Colony Beach Estates House2
- Compass Point Condo0
- Coquina Beach Condo0
- Cottage Colony West Condo3
- East Rocks House1
- Ferry Landing House1
- Gopher Walk House0
- Greenwood Village At The Dunes Mixed2
- Gulf Pines House2
- Gulf Shores House3
- Gumbo Limbo House6
- Heron's Landing Mixed6
- Ibis At The Sanctuary Condo0
- Island Woods House1
- Lakeside Villas At The Dunes Villa0
- Las Tiendas House0
- Leisure Acres Land0
- Little Lake Murex House1
- Loggerhead Cay Condo3
- Long Acre Lake Mixed1
- Los Colony House0
- Mariner Pointe Condo5
- Mitzi Lane House0
- Palm Lake Mixed0
- Sanctuary Golf Villages Condo1
- Sanibel Arms Condo1
- Sanibel Arms West Condo3
- Sanibel Bayous Mixed5
- Sanibel Estates House9
- Sanibel Highlands House6
- Sanibel Isles House2
- Sanibel Residential Mixed5
- Sanibel River House1
- Sanibel Shores Mixed3
- Sanibel Siesta Condo1
- Sanibel Surfside Condo0
- Sanibel Woodlands House1
- Sea Oats Mixed1
- Seagull Estates House1
- Seashells Of Sanibel Condo1
- Seaspray Of Sanibel Island House0
- Shell Harbor House8
- Starling Way House0
- Sunset South Condo3
- Sunward Of Sanibel Condo0
- Tamarind At The Reef Condo0
- Tennisplace Condo5
- The Colony Inn Condo0
- Villa Sanibel Condo0
- Villas Of Sanibel Condo0
- West Rocks Mixed0
- Yachtsman Cove House0
Other Sanibel, FL Homes & Condos Price Range Segments
Entry-Level
Entry-Level7
Premium
Premium12
High-End
High-End38
- Anhinga Estates House0
- Atrium Condo1
- Bird Lane House1
- Casa Del Sol House0
- Del Sega Mixed7
- Donax Village Condo1
- Eastwood Landings House1
- Gulf Ridge House3
- Gulfside Place Condo0
- Harbour Cottages Mixed0
- High Tide Condo0
- Island Beach Club Condo1
- Kings Crown Condo2
- Kinzie Island House1
- La Playa Condo0
- Las Conchas Del Mar House1
- Nutmeg Village Mixed1
- Periwinkle Park House1
- Pointe Santo De Sanibel Condo6
- Royale Tern Condo1
- Sabal Sands House0
- Sand Pointe Condo0
- Sandalfoot Condo1
- Sandpiper Beach Condo1
- Sanibel Moorings Condo4
- Seahawk House1
- Sealoft Village Condo0
- Seascape Of Sanibel Condo2
- Sedgemoor Condo0
- Shell Island Beach Club Condo1
- Signal Inn Villa3
- South Capers Land2
- Sundial East Of Sanibel Condo2
- Sundial West Of Sanibel Condo2
- Tantara Condo1
- Water Shadows House1
- Wedgewood Of Sanibel Condo1
- Wilcox House0
Sanibel, FL Nearby Cities
8.3 mi
$240K - $1.7M
$8K - $16K
9.7 mi
$199K - $11.9M
$2K - $15K
10.4 mi
$329K - $18.9M
$0 - $0
14.3 mi
$285K - $2.6M
$3K - $6K
15.2 mi
$150K - $3.9M
$0 - $0



