Owner & SellerHome ValuePricing
Counties
Broward County
Collier County
Lee County
Miami-Dade County
Palm Beach County
St. Lucie County

House in Sanibel, FL 33957
Butterknife, 2287 Starfish Ln

Share
Closed
$2.5M27.8%
$1,806,000
Estimate Payment
4
Beds
4
Baths
4,146
SqFt
Status
Sold - Aug 21, 2026
Parking
2
Size
4,146 SqFt (385 m2)
Price
$436/SqFt ($4,689/m2)
Type
House
Built
2003
HOA
$2,145/MO
MLS Number
2026034225
View
Landscaped Area, Partial Gulf
Updated
10 Days ago
Page Views
0
Welcome to Sanibel Island’s newest remodel in Butterknife, the only gated community on prestigious West Gulf Drive. Here you don’t have to choose between luxury and the beach lifestyle. It starts with the 18-foot-plus ceilings accentuated by clerestory windows... Read more

Features

Bedrooms
  • Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms
  • Bathrooms: 4
  • Half Bathrooms: No info
Exterior and Lot Features
  • Exterior Features: Open Porch/Lanai
  • View: Landscaped Area, Partial Gulf
Interior, Heating and Cooling
  • Interior Features: Cathedral Ceiling(s), Custom Mirrors, Fireplace, French Doors, Laundry Tub, Pantry
  • Equipment / Appliances: Dishwasher, Disposal, Microwave, Range, Refrigerator
  • Heating Description: Central Electric
  • Cooling Description: Ceiling Fan(s), Central Electric
Building and Construction
  • Floor Description: Tile
  • Windows/Treatment: No info
  • Construction Type: House
  • Year Built: 2003
  • Style: Two Story, Single Family
Waterfront and Water Access
  • Waterfront Frontage: No info
School Information
    Other Property Info
    • Garage: 2
    • Pets Allowed: Yes
    Taxes, Fees & More
    • Maintenance Includes: Legal/Accounting, Manager, Rec Facilities, Street Maintenance
    • Taxes: 14035.62
    • Security Information: Gated Community
    • Parking Description: Attached
    • Total Floors in Building: 2
    • Total Units in Building: 1

    Apples-to-Apples Comparables

     Closest-Match Comparables
    See closest-match comps for this subdivision
      Unlock Access
    No obligation
    Verified
    Trends
    Insights
    Seller Advisory
    A smarter move starts with the right information
    Get a complimentary hyperlocal market review with human agent-verified comps and pricing guidance
    01
    Market Review
    Local market intelligence
    02
    Verified Comps
    Human agent-verified comparables
    03
    Pricing Guidance
    Actionable pricing recommendations
    Complimentary. No obligation

    Price History

    Current
    $1.8M
    High
    $2.5M
    Low
    $1.8M
    Total Change
    -27.8%
    $2.6M$2.2M$1.7MAug 26Aug 26Aug 26
    Date
    Event
    Price
    Change
    Price Per
    08/21/2026
    Sold
    $1.8M
    0%
    $436 ft2
    $4,689 m2
    08/24/2026
    Price Reduced
    $1.8M
    -27.76%
    $436 ft2
    $4,689 m2
    08/12/2026
    Listed
    $2.5M
     
    $603 ft2
    $6,491 m2
    08/21/2026
    $1.8M
    Event
    Sold
    Change
    0%
    Price Per
    $436 ft2
    $4,689 m2
    08/24/2026
    $1.8M
    Event
    Price Reduced
    Change
    -27.76%
    Price Per
    $436 ft2
    $4,689 m2
    08/12/2026
    $2.5M
    Event
    Listed
    Price Per
    $603 ft2
    $6,491 m2
    Price per square foot and days on website are not provided values and are calculated by Subdivisions.
    Listed by Jeffrey Burns • Premier Sotheby's Int'l Realty • Buyer Agency Compensation .

    Listing Location & Street View
    MapStreet View

    Peer Listings

    Active listings from matched communities
    Results 0 of 0
    No listings found
    Try adjusting your filters or changing your location to see available listings
    Turn on listing alerts and we'll notify you
    when matching listings appear
    Community Snapshot
    5 – 5 BR
    Bedrooms
    $1.7M – $1.7M
    Price Tier
    2,572 - 4,146
    SqFt Range
    2003
    Year Build
    2
    Total Floors

    Subdivision Amenities

    Beach Access
    Community Room
    Pickleball
    Pool
    See Remarks
    Storage
    Tennis Court(s)
    Barbecue
    Beach - Private
    Beach Access
    Pool

    Sanibel
    Mid-Tier
     Mid-Tier Homes & Condos

    Logo

    The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity' Program of the Regional Multiple Listing Service of Miami Dade, Broward, Palm Beach, Collier and Lee Counties. Not all listings found on this site are necessarily listed through Subdivisions.com. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Subdivisions.com are marked with the Broker Reciprocity' logo or the Broker Reciprocity' thumbnail logo (little black house) and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers.

    Company
    About Us
    Press Room
    Blog
    Contact Us
    Legal
    Privacy Policy
    Terms of Use
    DMCA Notice
    Accessibility
    Social Media
    Facebook
    Instagram
    LinkedIn
    Pinterest
    Copyright © 2026 Subdivisions.com • All Rights Reserved • Made with ❤ in Miami, Florida.
    HomeSearchOwner & SellerHome Value