Catalina Isles, 8591 Sumner Ave

5
Beds
31/2
Baths
3,142
SqFt
Status
Sold - Dec 18, 2025
Parking
2
Size
3,142 SqFt (292 m2)
Price
$143/SqFt ($1,542/m2)
Type
House
Built
2009
HOA
$335/MO
MLS Number
2025014205
View
Lake
Updated
229 Days ago
Page Views
0
Welcome to Catalina Isles! This stunning 2-story single-family home with a beautiful water view offers 5 bedrooms, 3.5 baths, and over 3,100 sq ft of living space. Offering formal living/dining, plus family room, you will fall in love with the open feeling! ... Read more

Features

Bedrooms
  • Bedrooms: 5
Bathrooms
  • Bathrooms: 3
  • Half Bathrooms: 1
Exterior and Lot Features
  • Exterior Features: Screened Lanai/Porch
  • View: Lake
Interior, Heating and Cooling
  • Interior Features: Bar, Laundry Tub, Pantry, Walk-In Closet(s)
  • Equipment / Appliances: Dishwasher, Dryer, Microwave, Range, Refrigerator/Freezer, Washer
  • Heating Description: Central Electric
  • Cooling Description: Central Electric
Building and Construction
  • Floor Description: Carpet, Tile
  • Windows/Treatment: No info
  • Construction Type: House
  • Year Built: 2009
  • Style: Two Story, Single Family
Waterfront and Water Access
  • Waterfront Frontage: Yes
School Information
    Other Property Info
    • Garage: 2
    • Pets Allowed: Limits
    Taxes, Fees & More
    • Maintenance Includes: Internet/WiFi Access, Irrigation Water, Lawn/Land Maintenance, Legal/Accounting, Manager, Rec Facilities, Reserve, Security, Street Lights, Street Maintenance
    • Taxes: 4967.27
    • Security Information: Gated Community
    • Parking Description: Paved, Attached
    • Total Floors in Building: 2
    • Total Units in Building: No info

    Apples-to-Apples Comparables

     Closest-Match Comparables
    See closest-match comps for this subdivision
    No obligation
    Verified
    Trends
    Insights
    Seller Advisory
    A smarter move starts with the right information
    Get a complimentary hyperlocal market review with human agent-verified comps and pricing guidance
    01
    Market Review
    Local market intelligence
    02
    Verified Comps
    Human agent-verified comparables
    03
    Pricing Guidance
    Actionable pricing recommendations
    Complimentary. No obligation

    Price History

    Current
    $450K
    High
    $500K
    Low
    $450K
    Total Change
    -10%
    $506K$475K$444KOct 25Dec 25Dec 25
    Date
    Event
    Price
    Change
    Price Per
    12/18/2025
    Sold
    $450K
    0%
    $143 ft2
    $1,542 m2
    12/21/2025
    Price Reduced
    $450K
    -10%
    $143 ft2
    $1,542 m2
    10/25/2025
    Listed
    $500K
     
    $159 ft2
    $1,713 m2
    12/18/2025
    $450K
    Event
    Sold
    Change
    0%
    Price Per
    $143 ft2
    $1,542 m2
    12/21/2025
    $450K
    Event
    Price Reduced
    Change
    -10%
    Price Per
    $143 ft2
    $1,542 m2
    10/25/2025
    $500K
    Event
    Listed
    Price Per
    $159 ft2
    $1,713 m2
    Price per square foot and days on website are not provided values and are calculated by Subdivisions.
    Listed by Lisa BlanchardJohn R. Wood Properties • Buyer Agency Compensation .

    Listing Location & Street View
    MapStreet View

    Peer Listings

    Active listings from matched communities
    Results 2 of 2
    Camden Square, 12077 Winfield Cir, Fort Myers, Florida 33966, image 1
    Camden Square, 12077 Winfield Cir, Fort Myers, Florida 33966, image 2
    Camden Square, 12077 Winfield Cir, Fort Myers, Florida 33966, image 3
    $489,000 $21K
    • 4 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 2,176 SqFt
    • $225/SqFt
    House for sale in Camden Square
    12077 Winfield Cir, Fort Myers, FL 33966
    Beautiful lake views! Turnkey furnished and absolutely stunning! Enjoy lakefront living in this beautifully appointed four-bedroom home, complete with a versatile den/office, two full baths and a spacious two-car garage. Offering 2, 176 square feet of open-concept living, this home features a bright and airy layout with a showstopping oversized lanai that overlooks the serene lake. The gourmet kitchen is a chef’s dream, showcasing a large island with granite countertops, stylish backsplash, under-cabinet and overhead lighting, walk-in pantry and a deep sink — ideal for entertaining. Plantation shutters throughout the home. Adjacent to the kitchen is a formal dining room that flows seamlessly into the expansive family room filled with natural light. The private primary suite offers tranquil lake views, a walk-in shower, dual vanities, a generous walk-in closet and a separate linen closet for added storage. There are easy-to-use exterior manual hurricane shutters for added protection. In the gated community of camden square, residents enjoy resort-style amenities including a pool with cabana, basketball court, tot lot and a cozy outdoor fire pit. Ideally just minutes from rsw airport, jetblue park, hammond stadium, shopping, dining and the white-sand gulf beaches — this is southwest florida living at its best.
    Magnolia Lakes, 13338 Little Gem Cir, Fort Myers, Florida 33913, image 1
    Magnolia Lakes, 13338 Little Gem Cir, Fort Myers, Florida 33913, image 2
    Magnolia Lakes, 13338 Little Gem Cir, Fort Myers, Florida 33913, image 3
    $469,800 $10K
    • 4 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,929 SqFt
    • $244/SqFt
    House for sale in Magnolia Lakes
    13338 Little Gem Cir, Fort Myers, FL 33913
    This home is packed w/ custom luxury features and offers a sprawling layout from front door to lake! Recent updates include- freshly painted interior, plantation shutters, pavers have been cleaned & sealed, and custom tall cabinetry with high-end epoxy flooring in the 3-car garage. You will love the layout of the home- living & family room design, formal dining area, wide kitchen w/ breakfast bar & butler area, pantry w/ french doors, breakfast nook, crown molding, contemporary glass door at front entry, custom entertainment wall in family room w/ shiplap, and massive screened outdoor living space w/ saltwater heated pool & covered sitting area. Magnolia lakes is a gated community of all single family homes that offers a playground w/ picnic area. You will have access to all of gateway amenities including optional social/golf membership to the club. Very convenient location- minutes away from rsw international airport, i-75, spring training stadiums, schools, restaurants, grocery store, shopping and so much more!
    Community Snapshot
    3 to 5 BR
    Bedrooms
    $380K to $899K
    Price Tier
    1,672 - 4,489
    SqFt Range
    2007
    Year Build
    2
    Total Floors

    Fort Myers
    Entry-Level
    Entry-Level Homes & Condos

    HomeSearchHome ValueProfile